Case Study 6-1: Protein Adequacy
Erin is a 28-year-old professional woman who is 5 feet 8 inches tall and vigilantly maintains her weight at 118
pounds by following a lacto-ovo (non-fat milk and egg whites only) vegetarian diet that supplies approximately
1200 calories a day. With her understanding that protein should provide between 10 and 35 percent of her daily
calories, she reasons that her daily intake of 40 grams of protein from milk, eggs, legumes, and nuts is adequate for
her needs. She is concerned, however, that she has been sick more than usual and has experienced two stress
fractures in her leg over the past three years while exercising.
1. Explain why Erin’s assumptions about her protein needs are unrealistic based on her current weight.
2. Assuming a healthy weight for Erin is 141 pounds, use the information from the “How to” feature (p. 187) in
this chapter to calculate her recommended daily protein requirement. Show your calculations.
3. What percentage of Erin’s current energy intake comes from protein? Remember that protein provides
approximately 4 kcalories per gram.) Is this adequate? Why or why not?
4. Erin’s energy needs for a healthy weight are closer to 1600 calories a day. How might her low calorie intake
influence her protein status and possibly contribute to her current health issues?
5. How would you explain to Erin how her low intake of calories and protein contribute to her risk for
osteoporosis?
6. Assuming Erin consumes 20 grams of protein from whole grains, vegetables, and legumes each day, calculate
how she can meet the remainder of her protein needs with dairy foods and egg whites.
Answer Key
1. Protein needs are based on “healthy body weight.” Erin is underweight so her actual weight is not a good
parameter for calculating her protein needs. In addition, her total kcal intake is so low that a protein intake near
the low end of the 10-35% range is less than her protein requirement based on her current weight.
Case 6-2: Amino Acid Supplements
Danielle F. is a 78-year-old retired school teacher who is seeking ways to increase her protein intake. She does very
little cooking and avoids fish, poultry, and meat for personal reasons. She eats eggs occasionally but relies more on a
liquid amino acid product that claims to contain essential and non–essential amino acids in “naturally-occurring
amounts.”
Danielle decides to compare the protein quantity and quality of this product to an egg. Initially she learns that 1
whole egg contains 18 amino acids (9 essential amino acids and 9 non-essential amino acids). ½ teaspoon of liquid
amino acid product contains 16 amino acids (9 essential amino acids and 7 non-essential amino acids). Then she
examines the Nutrition Facts label for these two products. (See below.)