Data Analysis Problem
20. Rubisco of Bacterial Endosymbionts of Hydrothermal Vent Animals Undersea hydrothermal
vents support remarkable ecosystems. At these extreme depths there is no light to support photosyn-
thesis, yet thriving vent communities are found. Much of their primary productivity occurs through
chemosynthesis carried out by bacterial symbionts that live in specialized organs (trophosomes) of
certain vent animals.
Chemosynthesis in these bacteria involves a process that is virtually identical to photosynthesis.
Carbon dioxide is fixed by rubisco and reduced to glucose, and the necessary ATP and NADPH are
produced by electron-transfer processes similar to those of the light-dependent reactions of photosyn-
thesis. The key difference is that in chemosynthesis, the energy driving electron transfer comes from a
highly exergonic chemical reaction rather than from light. Different chemosynthetic bacteria use dif-
ferent reactions for this purpose. The bacteria found in hydrothermal vent animals typically use the
oxidation of H
2
S (abundant in the vent water) by O
2
, producing elemental sulfur. These bacteria also
use the conversion of H
2
S to sulfur as a source of electrons for chemosynthetic CO
2
reduction.
(a) What is the overall reaction for chemosynthesis in these bacteria? You do not need to write a
balanced equation; just give the starting materials and products.
(b) Ultimately, these endosymbiotic bacteria obtain their energy from sunlight. Explain how this
occurs.
Robinson and colleagues (2003) explored the properties of rubisco from the bacterial endosym-
biont of the giant tube worm Riftia pachyptila. Rubisco, from any source, catalyzes the reaction of
either CO
2
(Fig. 20–7) or O
2
(Fig. 20–20) with ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate. In general, rubisco reacts
more readily with CO
2
than O
2
. The degree of selectivity () can be expressed as
where Vis the reaction velocity.
Robinson and coworkers measured the value for the rubisco of the bacterial endosymbionts.
They purified rubisco from tube-worm trophosomes, reacted it with mixtures of different ratios of O
2
and CO
2
in the presence of [1-
3
H]ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate, and measured the ratio of [
3
H]phospho-
glycerate to [
3
H]phosphoglycolate.
(c) The measured ratio of [
3
H]phosphoglycerate to [
3
H]phosphoglycolate is equal to the ratio
V
carboxylation
兾V
oxygenation
. Explain why.
(d) Why would [5-
3
H]ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate not be a suitable substrate for this assay?
The for the endosymbiont rubisco had a value of 8.6 0.9.
(e) The atmospheric (molar) concentration of O
2
is 20% and that of CO
2
is about 380 parts per million. If
the endosymbiont were to carry out chemosynthesis under these atmospheric conditions, what
would be the value of V
carboxylation
/V
oxygenation
?
(f) Based on your answer to (e), would you expect for the rubisco of a terrestrial plant to be
higher than, the same as, or lower than 8.6? Explain your reasoning.
Two stable isotopes of carbon are commonly found in the environment: the more abundant
12
C
and the rare
13
C. All rubisco enzymes catalyze the fixation of
12
CO
2
faster than that of
13
CO
2
. As a
result, the carbon in glucose is slightly enriched in
12
C compared with the isotopic composition of CO
2
in the environment. Several factors are involved in this “preferential” use of
12
CO
2
, but one factor is
the fundamental physics of gases. The temperature of a gas is related to the kinetic energy of its mole-
cules. Kinetic energy is given by 1⁄2mv
2
, where mis molecular mass and vis velocity. Thus, at the same
temperature (same kinetic energy), the molecules of a lighter gas will be moving faster than those of a
heavier gas.
(g) How could this contribute to rubisco’s “preference” for
12
CO
2
over
13
CO
2
?
Some of the first convincing evidence that the tube-worm hosts were obtaining their fixed carbon
from the endosymbionts was that the
13
C/
12
C ratio in the animals was much closer to that of the bacte-
ria than that of nonvent marine animals.
[CO
2
]
[O
2
]
V
carboxylation
V
oxygenation
Chapter 20 Carbohydrate Biosynthesis in Plants and Bacteria S-245