24. Retinoblastoma in Children Explain why some children with retinoblastoma develop multiple tu-
mors of the retina in both eyes, whereas others have a single tumor in only one eye.
25. Specificity of a Signal for a Single Cell Type Discuss the validity of the following proposition. A
signaling molecule (hormone, growth factor, or neurotransmitter) elicits identical responses in differ-
ent types of target cells if they contain identical receptors.
Data Analysis Problem
26. Exploring Taste Sensation in Mice Figure 12–42 shows the signal-transduction pathway for sweet
taste in mammals. Pleasing tastes are an evolutionary adaptation to encourage animals to consume
nutritious foods. Zhao and coauthors (2003) examined the two major pleasurable taste sensations:
sweet and umami. Umami is a “distinct savory taste” triggered by amino acids, especially aspartate and
glutamate, and probably encourages animals to consume protein-rich foods. Monosodium glutamate
(MSG) is a flavor enhancer that exploits this sensitivity.
At the time the article was published, specific taste receptor proteins (labeled SR in Fig. 12–42)
for sweet and umami had been tentatively characterized. Three such proteins were known—T1R1,
T1R2, and T1R3—which function as heterodimeric receptor complexes: T1R1-T1R3 was tentatively
identified as the umami receptor, and T1R2-T1R3 as the sweet receptor. It was not clear how taste
sensation was encoded and sent to the brain, and two possible models had been suggested. In the cell-
based model, individual taste-sensing cells express only one kind of receptor; that is, there are “sweet
cells,” “bitter cells,” “umami cells,” and so on, and each type of cell sends its information to the brain
via a different nerve. The brain “knows” which taste is detected by the identity of the nerve fiber that
transmits the message. In the receptor-based model, individual taste-sensing cells have several kinds
of receptors and send different messages along the same nerve fiber to the brain, the message depend-
ing on which receptor is activated. Also unclear at the time was whether there was any interaction be-
tween the different taste sensations, or whether parts of one taste-sensing system were required for
other taste sensations.
(a) Previous work had shown that different taste receptor proteins are expressed in nonoverlapping
sets of taste receptor cells. Which model does this support? Explain your reasoning.
Zhao and colleagues constructed a set of “knockout mice”—mice homozygous for loss-of-function
alleles for one of the three receptor proteins, T1R1, T1R2, or T1R3—and double-knockout mice with
nonfunctioning T1R2 and T1R3. The researchers measured the taste perception of these mice by mea-
suring their “lick rate” of solutions containing different taste molecules. Mice will lick the spout of a
feeding bottle with a pleasant-tasting solution more often than one with an unpleasant-tasting solution.
The researchers measured relative lick rates: how often the mice licked a sample solution compared
with water. A relative lick rate of 1 indicated no preference; ⬍1, an aversion; and ⬎1, a preference.
(b) All four types of knockout strains had the same responses to salt and bitter tastes as did wild-
type mice. Which of the above issues did this experiment address? What do you conclude from
these results?