496 Brooks ◼ Financial Management: Core Concepts, 4e
© 2018 Pearson Education, Inc.
b) If 85% of the shares are sold, i.e., 850,000 shares at $11 per share, the proceeds are as
follows:
1) With the firm commitment arrangement, the issuer gets $8,500,000
The investment banker gets $9,350,000 – $8,500,000 = $$850,000
2) With the best efforts arrangement, the issuer gets ($11 – $1.50) * 850,000 ➔
$8,075,000
The investment banker gets $1.5*850,000➔$1,275,000
➔So if the issue is only 85% sold, the issuer is better off with a firm commitment offer while
the investment banker would be better off with the best efforts arrangement.
c) Firm commitment offer = best effort $ per share sold
$8,500,000 = $9.50*1,000,000 * X% ➔ X% = $8,500,000/$9,500,000 ➔89.47%
So, if 89.47% of the shares are sold, the payment to the investment banking firm will be the
same under either arrangement.
Registration, Prospectus, and Tombstone: All new issues of shares have to be registered
with the SEC prior to being sold in the capital markets.
Once an application is filed, the approval process could take anywhere from twenty to forty days
(cool-off period). During the waiting period, the issuer can circulate a preliminary prospectus
(red herring) informing potential investors of the issue. No commitments can be obtained from
buyers until after SEC approval. If information is missing, the SEC issues a comment letter,
requiring corrections and a new application to be filed. Once re-filed, the cool-off period starts
again.
During the waiting period, the issuer and investment bank place large advertisements
(tombstone ads) in newspapers and magazines, containing the name of the issuer, some details
about the issue, and a list of participating investment banks.
There are two exceptions to the usual SEC registration process requirement:
The Marketing Process: Road Show: This stage involves taking the issue on the road to
attract interest among potential investors. This process usually last about two weeks and
enables the investment banker to get a feel for what the price should be set at. After a
successful road show and marketing campaign, a price is set and the issue proceeds forward to
be auctioned off in the primary capital market.
The auction: takes place on a single trading day, during which time buyers submit their bids at
preset prices. If over-subscribed, the bids are filled on a pro-rata basis until all the shares are
sold.