Chapter 10 – Bond Prices and Yields
During the credit crisis of 2008 the spread between Treasury bonds and junk-bond yields widened from 3%
in 2007 to 15% at the start of 2009! Many blame the crisis on excessive use of exotic derivatives such as
CDSs. They are partly correct, but the large number of factors led to the crisis. These include excess
leverage, lax regulation, excessively cheap credit, congressional interference in the mortgage markets.
Currency manipulation by export driven countries, unethical mortgage originators and misaligned executive
pay incentives all played a significant role as well, along with major failures of the ratings agencies to
identify the level of risk involved in mortgage securities.
Ratings agencies are paid by the firms issuing the securities. This creates a large conflict of interest
between the issuer and the bond rater. The government has granted a monopoly to the top three rating
agencies, although others exist. Even now, participation in TALF funding requires the securities be rated
by one of the big three (Moody’s, S&P and Fitches). We have known for a long time that bond prices move
ahead of announced downgrades in ratings. This is probably not due to information leakage ahead of the
announced change, but rather due to the slowness of the agency to respond and the unwillingness to
downgrade. Extrapolation bias also exists in the current agency-based paradigm as explained below.
A credit default swap (CDS) is an insurance policy on the default risk of a bond or loan. The seller of the
swap collects an annual premium (and sometimes an upfront fee) from the swap buyer. The buyer of the
Obviously if the economy experiences greater than expected defaults, these contracts magnify the losses
many times over resulting in a series of defaults. More detail can help students to understand this problem.
With a CDS there was no principal investment required; a low capital requirement (important if regulated);
and with a strong seller credit rating, little collateral was required. The result was excessive risk taking on
both sides. Buyers took on more risk because they were insured, even though insurer’s collateral was
As the text points out, the lack of transparency in this market helped cause the credit freeze after the
subprime mortgage crisis began. No one could tell the obligations and exposure of counterparties so it was
too risky to make a loan. AIG had over $400 billion in CDS contracts on subprime mortgages and other
loans and was going bankrupt. The failure of AIG might have trigged defaults at other institutions that
were counting on payments from AIG to protect their own investments. Ultimately the government decided
6. The Yield Curve
PPT 10-42 through PPT 10-47
The term structure of interest rates depicts the relationship between term to maturity and maturity for a
group of bonds that are identical in all aspects except maturity. In practice, identical means the same
rating, preferably the same coupon so that you don’t get into tax differences.
10–4