IM – 2 | 10
out of view of the student’s partner. Then, tell the students in each pair to exchange
envelopes.
8. When that portion of the exercise is finished, tell students to open their envelopes and
determine whether their partners honored their agreement or not. Within each pair, four
outcomes are possible: 1) both partners honored the agreement; 2) partner A honored the
agreement but partner B defected; 3) partner A defected but partner B honored the
agreement; 4) both partners defected.
9. By show of hands, ask the students who interacted with a same-group other how many of
them defected on their partners (i.e., how many failed to honor whatever agreement they
made with their partner). Next, ask the same question of students who interacted with a
student from the opposite group. Typically, a higher percentage of students will defect
against someone from the opposing team than against someone from their own team. If that
is the case, then use the exercise to generate discussion about in-group and out-group
principles. Point out that the in-group/out-group distinction is powerful—the two groups only
differed in the color of Post-It note they had on their shirts, but that was enough to activate
their motivation to cooperate more with in-group members than out-group members.
In-Class Exercise B: Culture/Gender Challenges in a Hat
1. This exercise focuses on students’ own challenges when communicating with people of
different cultures or genders (it is best to select either culture or gender, not both, for this
exercise). It is a simple exercise that can be done in 15–20 minutes.
2. It’s very important that an atmosphere of respect and dignity be created and maintained in
the classroom before and during this exercise. Encourage students to be honest with their
responses, but emphasize that students are not to critique or criticize each other.
3. Give each student a slip of paper. On their piece of paper, have students briefly describe one
challenge they have experienced when communicating with someone of a different cultural
or gender group, one question they have about other cultures/genders, or one observation
they can make about how another culture/gender communicates (based on their own
experience). Once everyone has written, have students fold their slips of paper and then
deposit them into a box, a large bowl, or a hat. Mix them up as best you can.
4. Pass the hat (or box, or bowl) around the class. One at a time, have each student draw out one
response and read it aloud to the class. Then, ask that student to respond to what was written.
Students can express agreement or disagreement, offer their own experience, or speculate on
an answer (if a question was posed). Reinforce that students are to respond only to what was
written, not to attack the presumed author. The class is not to respond to the student
speaking; rather, each student draws a slip of paper, reads it, responds to it, and then you
move onto the next student.
5. At the end of the exercise, use the writings and students’ oral responses to them to generate
discussion about culture and/or gender. What written or oral comments did students find the
most surprising? The most provocative? The most discomforting?