Case 13.1
There is a major conflict going on in Andy’s department. Workers do not trust Andy.
They resent his authoritarian style, and they resist his instructions and suggestions.
Andy sees the workers as “drones,” and they think of him as “Darth Vader.” Initially,
Andy’s manager tells the workers to “put up with it” and to “get back to work.” He
refuses to listen to their complaints and imposes his instructions with a threat of
discipline. A group of employees discusses the problem. Jane suggests that they just
drop it and go back to work. She doesn’t want to lose her job and fears that even if they
win, their working relationship with Andy will be damaged beyond repair. Malcolm
suggests that they go back to Andy’s boss and explain that they think talking about
Andy’s behavior could improve productivity and quality. He tells the group they ought
to write down and present the substance of their concerns, not just attack Andy’s
management style. Malcolm thinks they can work this out without removing Andy or
getting fired themselves.
Refer to Case 13.1. By presenting the substance of their concerns, Malcolm is engaging
in which step of the conflict resolution process?
a. Deciding between a misunderstanding or a disagreement
b. Defining the problem
c. Clarifying perceptions
d. Generating options for mutual gain
Case 10.1
Antonio’s company has an employee orientation program; an extensive employee
performance review program; and encourages managers to praise, write letters of
appreciation for jobs well done, and take the time to listen to their employees. Years
ago, the company began a positive reinforcement program. Managers were initially
reluctant to support the program because they expected employees to begin demanding
pay raises. But the company kept working at it, and eventually the program was
accepted. Then, in order to increase quality and productivity, assembly-line workers
were paid based on piecework for each acceptable component that they built. When the
incentive programs were first introduced, employees competed with each other,
teamwork was destroyed, and interpersonal relations dropped to an all-time low. Now
the incentive programs and other positive reinforcement programs seem to be working.
However, due to cutbacks in management levels and increasing work demands,
managers are finding it harder and harder to determine which employees most deserve
recognition.