Synthesizing what you have learned throughout this chapter and others, what role does
ethics play in persuasive speaking? Why would we say that behaving ethically increases
a speaker’s chances of being successful at persuasive speaking? How does ethics relate
to logical fallacies?
Consider the topic of the death penalty. First, construct a proposition of fact, a
proposition of value, and a proposition of policy that would support elimination of the
death penalty. What needs could a speaker taking a stance in repealing the death penalty
appeal to in his or her speech? Second, construct a proposition each of fact, value, and
policy that would support use of the death penalty for capital crimes. What needs could
a speaker taking this position appeal to in his or her speech?
Council member Dee Jackson finds herself in a difficult position. She firmly believes
that approving a casino project to move forward in her community will stimulate the
economy of the district she represents and will provide the money that is needed to fund
both their ailing public schools and several public works projects that are critically
needed. Unfortunately, she has discovered that her constituents and the other members
of the city council oppose the casino being located in their community. Synthesizing
what you have learned in this chapter, what advice do you have for Ms. Jackson? What
should she consider as she develops her proposal and presents her appeal to her
audience?
Research shows that when liking and credibility come into conflict, credibility carries
more weight. We are likely to be less moved by the speech even if we like the speaker.
Apply this to national politics and provide examples of this element of ethos.