11-131
362. U.S. President Obama nominated New York Judge Sonia Sotamayor to the Supreme
Court, to fill the position vacated by Justice Sutter. At the hearings that preceded the vote
by the Senate, there was extensive discussion about Judge Sotamayor’s past speeches
where she alluded to a sensitivity toward minority problems and situations due to the fact
that she is a Hispanic minority and a woman. The concern by many senators is that the
law should be applied equally among all groups in the U.S.; in fact, some were worried
about reverse discrimination. Others favored the fact that her background would bring a
different perspective to the court. Although there are differences between an appointment
to the Supreme Court and appointing employees to management positions, there are also
similarities in these actions. High profile positions and appointments serve as examples.
From a business perspective, why might such an action be a good thing?
A. Creating a diverse supreme court is never a good idea. It will certainly lend itself to
more laws similar to affirmative action and other hiring issues.
B. Businesses always follow the lead of politicians and political appointments. Companies
now have a “heads-up” that their competitors will start campaigns to promote minorities to
top positions.
C. Creating a team of diverse individuals working for your business will help you make
decisions based on a variety of perspectives, and ultimately to attract and retain a diverse
group of customers.
D. It’s unethical and illegal to pass-up a minority candidate that is equally qualified. The
senators had no choice but to confirm this nomination, and they are warning businesses
that they must do the same, or face future repercussions.
Feedback: Companies that take the initiative to groom women and minorities for management
positions are expanding their pool of talent. When a business has diversity in its workforce, it
lends itself to attracting and satisfying the diverse groups of customers that it serves.
363.