Exercise 9
NOTE: If you are having any issues seeing logic symbols in this Word document, select “Read”
mode under the View menu in MS Word. PDF versions of the Instructor Manual are also
available on the Instructor Companion Site.
Chapter 9
Exercise 9
Part II
1. a. Has no affect. f. Strengthens.
2. a. Strengthens. f. Strengthens.
5. a. Strengthens f. Strengthens.
Exercise 9
b. Strengthens. g. Weakens.
9. The central issue is whether Dr. Wacko’s occupancy of Mica Peak was open, notorious, and
hostile. For Dr. Wacko’s argument, note the fact that every evening for 20 years he could be
10. For Maxie’s argument, concentrate on the similarities between a home and a car (a car is an
extended living space with heating, air conditioning, stereo, telephone, etc.), the
dissimilarities between a plane and a car (greater difficulty in controlling, ease of crossing
international borders, greater danger in operating, etc.). Also, people outside U.S. borders
Exercise 9
11. In support of the group, note the fact that the Gay Freedom Day parade involves sexual
expression just as Lester’s paintings did, and Lester’s First Amendment rights were upheld.
Indeed, the parade probably would have been less offensive than the paintings because it
12. In favor of Isabel, note that constant noise is at least as disruptive as cold temperatures.
Without sleep, Isabel’s efficiency at work would undoubtedly be impaired, and thus her
Exercise 9
livelihood would be adversely affected. Linder could at least get some sleep by purchasing
an electric blanket that would keep out the cold, but it is doubtful that earplugs would be
equally effective for Isabel. Also, Carolyn’s decision not to enforce the noise clause in the
lease was a free act on her part, just as was Garvin’s decision not to provide heat. If Garvin
13. For Liz’s argument note that there were several events that intervened between the car
accident and the amputation: Mary’s being taken to the hospital, Mary’s being treated by
doctors for bumps and bruises, Mary’s apparent mix-up with some other patient scheduled
Exercise 9