tend to concentrate on only the most expensive, fast-moving merchandise. For the retailer,
another issue is that salespeople compensated primarily by incentives don’t develop loyalty
to their employer. Incentives are less effective with inexperienced salespeople, who are less
confident in their skills, because they inhibit learning and also can cause excessive stress.
Because compensation plans based (almost) exclusively on sales incentives generally fail to
promote good customer service, some plans include a fixed salary plus a commission on
total sales or a commission on sales over quota.
7. When evaluating retail employees, some stores use a quantitative approach that relies on
checklists and numerical scores similar to the form in Exhibit 15-5. Other stores use a
more qualitative approach similar to the form in Exhibit 15-4, whereby less time is spent
checking and adding and more time is devoted to discussing strengths and weaknesses in
written form. What are the advantages and disadvantages of quantitative versus
qualitative evaluation systems?
Each evaluation approach has its strengths. Quantitative methods are useful in that they
provide a scale that can be utilized uniformly across departments and stores. This enables
evaluators to get a more balanced appraisal of performance from a broad perspective. In
addition, quantitative methods leave little question as to the relevant evaluative criteria,
8. Some staff pharmacists working for retail chains refuse to dispense the Plan B “morning
after” contraceptive pill because of their religious beliefs. In another situation, Muslims
and Jewish checkout clerks working for supermarket chains refused to touch, scan, or bag
products that contained any pork because of their religious beliefs. Do managers have
the right to force employees to take actions that are contrary to their beliefs? Should
customers be unable to buy products they want because of an employee’s beliefs? Should
employees be required to ignore their religious beliefs? What would you do if you were
faced with these or similar ethically sensitive situations?