Chapter 13: Paid Media
Movie giant Screenvision now offers a 20-minute preshow called The Limelight
as a mobile app that lets viewers watch trailers, search for showtimes, and earn
points toward free movie tickets and concession snacks. They can also play video
Video Game Advertising
Marketers and media planners have been frustrated trying to reach young people with
traditional ads on mainstream media. That has led to an increased focus on unusual
media that are clearly the province of young people, such as video games.
Now a global multi-billion-dollar industry, the video game business is developing as
a major new medium for advertisers to target 12- to 34-year-old males, although girls
are getting into the act as well. And, Wii is bringing in an older adult audience of both
men and women with its sports and exercise programs.
Place-Based Media
What we call out-of-home media or place-based media include everything from
billboards to hot-air balloons. That means ads on public spaces, including buses,
posters on building walls (barn roofs in the old days), telephone and shopping kiosks,
painted and wrapped cars and semis, taxi signs and mobile billboards, transit shelters
and rail platforms, airport and bus terminal displays, hotel and shopping mall
displays, in-store merchandising signs, grocery store carts, shopping bags, public
restroom walls, skywriting, in-store clocks, and aisle displays.
Although total spending on out-of-home media is hard to determine because of the
industry’s diversity, this category is second only to the internet as the fastest-growing
marketing communication industry.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Outdoor Advertising
Of the $9 billion spent on outdoor advertising in 2016, billboard ads accounted for
approximately 60 percent; street furniture, such as signs on benches, transit ads, and
alternative forms (e.g., cinema, shopping malls, wallscapes) brought in the rest. Outdoor
advertising refers to billboards along streets and highways as well as posters in other
public locations.
In terms of size and format, there are two traditional kinds of billboards, bulletins and
posters, as well as digital billboards:
The billboards along major highways are called bulletins. Painted outdoor bulletins
range in size from 10 feet by 30 feet to 14 feet by 48 feet.
Posters are generally about half the width of bulletins, at 10 feet by 22 feet, but can
run as small as 5 feet by 11 feet.
Vinyl is the material of choice for both bulletins and posters because it has a brighter
appearance, UV defensive paint, and is much longer lasting than painted boards.
The outdoor landscape was dominated by large roadside billboards, but is now
experiencing a paradigm shift as static ad displays are being converted to digital
units.
For advertisers the conversion to digital, in addition to digital’s lower production
costs and shorter lead times, provides greater availability, scalability, and
flexibility on content, as illustrated in Figure 13.3.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Advertisers can purchase any number of units (75, 50, or 25 showings daily are
common quantities). Boards are usually rented for 30-day periods, with longer
periods possible. Painted bulletins are bought on an individual basis, usually for one,
two, or three years.
The cost of outdoor advertising is based on the percent of population in a specified
geographical area exposed to the ad in one day. Based on a traffic count, the number
of vehicles passing a particular location during a specified period of time is called a
Because of the very short time consumers are normally exposed to a traditional
billboard message (typically, three to five seconds), the message must be short and
the visual must be very attention getting. No more than 8 to 10 words is the norm.
The “Practical Tips” box identifies key features of outdoor media and provides
suggestions on how to design effective attention-getting messages for this “gigantic
canvas.”
New and Novel Forms
Innovation is important for the out-of-home industry with some boards now equipped
to run mini-movies and ads electronically. Some digitally enhanced outdoor boards
Unique Uses for Billboards and Posters
Posters may appear on the sides of buildings, construction sites, and even vehicles.
Empty storefronts in prime downtown locations and major thoroughfares have
become the latest venue for posting posters. With their large expanse of window
space, abandoned retail stores have become a frugal way to deliver a big message
during the recession.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Transit Advertising
This is mainly an urban mass advertising form that places ads on vehicles such as
buses and taxis that circulate through the community as moving billboards. Transit
advertising also includes the posters seen in bus shelters and train, airport, and
subway stations.
Most of these posters must be designed for quick impressions, although people who
are waiting on subway platforms or bus shelters often study these posters, so here
There are two types of transit advertising – interior and exterior.
Interior transit advertising is seen by people riding inside buses, subway cars,
and taxis. These are primarily posters or car cards, sometimes with coupons or
other forms of tear-off information that can be taken away. These can be designed
like outdoor boards with simple messages, but because the riders are largely a
designs on the sides both long haul and delivery trucks.
Event Advertising and Sponsorships
Ads at events and stadiums are another type of out-of-home media. Some are electronic,
but many are printed posters. Ads also appear all over cars at races as well as on their
driver’s outfits. Companies pay huge fees, as sponsors, in order to get their logos in
prominent positions.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
ONLINE ADVERTISING
Internet advertising can be delivered to a website as a traditional display ad, or it can
be presented in other formats, such as banner ads across the top or bottom of a Web
page.
The greatest percentage of internet advertising is found on a small group of large,
established sites that operate as electronic publishers, such as www.nytimes.com,
www.wsj.com, and www.espn.com, as well as on major search engines and service
providers, such as Google and Yahoo!. These media and search organizations have
established reputations, and they know how to sell advertising.
Mobile is no longer a trend. It’s now an integral part of everyday life for millions
of consumers worldwide, and no other device is so ingrained in consumer behavior.
On average, people in the United States spend three hours a day on their mobile
devices.
Facebook suggests measurement should focus not on “clicks” but rather on brand
advertising image and relationship building. To capture more advertising dollars
heading to mobile platforms, Facebook has been beefing up its “Audience Network,”
which lets marketers buy ads across the internet using Facebook’s data.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Although online advertising continues to be a hot topic at industry seminars, there are
some critics who question its effectiveness. Michael Wolff, who blogs on Technology
Review, says that people’s behavior on the web and how they interact with
advertising is different from traditional media. He charges that “the character of those
ads themselves and their inability to command real attention, has meant a marked
decline in advertising’s impact.”
Website Advertising
Here are some common, as well as novel, formats:
Skyscrapers are the extra-long, skinny ads running down the right or left side of a
website. Response rates for skyscrapers, which began to be used aggressively by
more companies in the early 2000s, can be 10 times higher than for traditional banner
ads.
Pop-ups and pop-behinds burst open on the computer screen either in front of or
behind the opening page of the website. They are seen as intrusive and annoying, so
some internet advertisers have moved away from this format, and some computer
software programs block them.
Micro-sites or mini-sites are small websites that are the offspring of a parent website,
such as the TDI Diesel site on the corporate VW site. For marketing purposes, the
micro-site may cover particular products, campaigns, events, or promotions.
Microsites tend to be more tightly focused than their parent sites and may be
Superstitials are thought of as the “Internet’s commercial” and are designed to work
like television ads. When you go from one page on a website to another, a 20-second
animation appears in a window.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Widgets are tiny computer programs that allow people to create and insert professional
looking content into their personal websites and also onto their television screens.
They include news notes, calculators, weather feeds, stock tickers, clocks, book or
music covers, or other web gadgets that can be a brand-name promotional offer. It’s a
way to get a nonintrusive brand reminder ad on the desktop, website, or blog.
Widgets also refer to mini applications that pull content from some other place on
the web and add it to your site. In addition to getting onto cell phone screens and
social media pages, they also can monitor contacts when someone clicks on the
feature.
Designers of online ads, mobile apps, and products are increasingly turning to the
processes and principles of User experience design (UX) and User interface design
(UI) in order to maximize usefulness and accessibility to consumers, and to improve
product websites so that visitors stay longer.
The UX process originated in the field of ergonomics and focuses on the entire
customer experience with a product or ad, and, as the figure shows, often includes
field research, product design, prototyping, and learning from customer testing
and feedback.
The UI process focuses on the look, feel, and layout of the ad or product interface
and enhancing its attractiveness and interactivity with consumers.
Research generally finds that the click-through rate nearly doubles when motion and
an interactive element are added to a banner ad–and that’s true for display ads as well.
Principle: The click-through rate nearly doubles when motion and an interactive
element are added to a banner ad—or to any form of online advertising.
Click-Throughs
Copyright © 2019 Pearson Education, Inc.
295
smartphones than desktop computers.
The difference in click-through response lies in the creativity and attention-getting
power of the banner ad or ad and where it is placed. The more related and relevant a
site is to the brand, the more likely it will generate a higher level of click-throughs.
Principle: The more relevant a website is to the brand, the more likely an ad will
generate a higher level of click-through.
Online Video Ads
Website visitors or viewers watching video downloads also confront a variety of
online video ads. There are about 30 formats available, so advertisers who want to use
video are struggling to find the best platform for their ads. The most common are in a
pre-roll format, which forces viewers to watch a video ad before viewing video
clips.
Other formats include interactive video ads that drop down over the screen and
allow viewers to click for more information and videos that allow viewers to click
on hot spots or buttons within the video to learn more about a product.
Online Classified Ads
A small part of the online advertising world is classified advertising, whether through
local media websites or Craigslist. The move to online “want ads” has been a big
contributor to the financial trouble that local newspapers find themselves in.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Search Advertising
People do hundreds of millions of searches a day on their computers, smart phones,
tablets, and other electronic devices. Estimates for the percentage of internet
advertising that goes to sites connected with search advertising range from 50 to 80
percent, which indicates how important the search function is for consumers and the
marketers who are trying to reach them.
Search providers, such as Google, MSN, Bing, and Yahoo!, auction off positions that
let advertisers’ ads be seen next to specific search results. Google AdWords is the
leading platform available for search advertising, supplying most of Google’s revenue
each year. It functions on a “pay per click” basis; that is, advertisers only pay when
their ad is clicked and the user is connected to their website.
A benefit of online consumer searches is that they leave a trail of clues about
products, features, and advertising approaches. This behavior can be mined for
insights that lead to new products.
With a credit card and a few minutes, a small business owner can set up a link
between his or her brand and a key word or key terms. It’s the ultimate in brand
linkage and interest association. Because consumers initiate the search, the adjoining
ads are not perceived to be as intrusive as other forms of advertising. In 2013, the
Federal Trade Commission expressed concern that search engines would often bring
up content that might not be identified as paid advertisements and laid out guidelines
to help visitors more clearly distinguish ads from other types of information.
The practice of maximizing the link between topics and brand-related websites is
called search optimization. Companies try to affect their search engine rankings to
drive more traffic to their websites. To have maximum visibility, they want their ads
to appear as close to the top of the list as possible. An important first step for
marketers in creating a viable website is getting it registered with popular search
engines so that it shows up early on the list provided by the search engine.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Another type of consumer search using smart phones is based on a quick-response
code, which is a type of two-dimensional bar code that uses a scannable matrix
design of square dots. You see them in ads and articles, on packages, and the sides of
buildings, anywhere a company wants to post this code as a scannable link to its
website. The point is that this is just one more way consumers can search for
information using their mobile phones.
Online Advertising Sales
Selling online advertising space is complicated. Major sites, such as MSNBC.com and
History.com, sell ads on their pages charging premium prices because they are on high-
traffic sites. They can cost from $10 to $50 per thousand viewings, depending on the
visibility of the position.
DoubleClick emphasizes the importance of building a web presence that is optimized
for mobile, reporting that advertisers can double their mobile ad revenue if their
mobile sites load in 5 seconds versus 19 seconds and that more than half of mobile
site visits are abandoned if they take longer than 3 seconds to load.
Middlemen companies act as brokers for online ad space that they aggregate across
different sites and package as single buys, in effect setting up an ad network. This ad
networker offers less well-designed sites and may sell space for less than a dollar per
thousand viewers. They are criticized for flooding the internet with cheap and
sometimes tacky ads.
Google, Microsoft, and AOL have set up ad exchanges that allow advertisers to bid
directly on available ad space on large groups of websites. In effect, they are cutting
out the middlemen. Other big websites, such as ESPN, Turner Broadcasting, and
Forbes magazine, have stopped doing business with the ad networks in order to gain
better control over the quality of the content on their sites.
Chapter 13: Paid Media
Digital Issues for Traditional Media
Some newspapers and magazines have “bundled” subscriptions that include print,
digital, and apps for smart phones and tablets. Others offer separate subscription rates
for print, digital, and/or app packages.
For television, more and more cable customers are “cord-cutting,” or moving away
from television services that require a fixed contract and buying on-demand options
instead. These on-demand options are called over-the-top content, which refers to
audio, video, and other media content delivered over the internet without the
involvement of a traditional provider such as cable or satellite TV.
Consumers must disconnect their TVs from the internet if they wish to avoid the ads,
meaning that they won’t be able to use streaming providers such as Netflix, Hulu, or
Amazon Prime. Viewers have not been happy.
END-OF-CHAPTER SUPPORT
REVIEW QUESTIONS
13-3. Explain how newspapers vary based on frequency of publication, format and
size, and circulation.
Most newspapers are published either daily or weekly. Daily newspapers are usually
found in cities and larger towns and have morning editions, evening editions, or all-day
editions.
Copyright © 2019 Pearson Education, Inc.
299
13-4. Explain how newspaper readership is determined and measured, and how
readership differs from circulation.
Newspapers measure their audiences to assess their performance and spot growth
opportunities. They also use readership data to attract advertisers who want to reach their
readers. Newspapers obtain objective measures of newspaper circulation and readership
by subscribing to one or both of the following auditing companies: the Auditing Bureau
13-5. What are the advantages of magazine advertising?
Most American adults read at least one magazine per month, and they spend more time
with magazines than with other print media. Color and quality of reproduction are the
biggest strengths of magazines. They allow the advertiser’s products and brand image to
be presented in a format superior to the quality of newspapers. People tend to pay more
13-6. What is the greatest advantage of using outdoor advertising? Of directory
advertising?
Outdoor advertising has the advantage of being a high-impact medium offering larger-
than-life visuals, on a hard-to-ignore structure. It is valued as a directional medium
because it tells someone how to find a business establishment. It can also serve as a brand
Copyright © 2019 Pearson Education, Inc.
300
13-7. How can radio be used most effectively, and what are the advantages and
limitations of advertising on radio?
To maximize the impact of a radio spot, timing is critical and depends upon
understanding when the target audience is most likely to be responsive. For example,
restaurants run spots before meals; auto dealerships run spots on Friday and Saturday,
when people are free to visit showrooms; jewelry stores run spots before Christmas.
Radio buys can be used at the local level to supplement national television and cable and
can act as a reminder.
13-8. How can television be used most effectively, and what are the advantages and
limitations of advertising on television?
A media buyer must be thoroughly familiar with all of the various television options,
including network, local, and cable. For example, networks allow sponsorships,
participations, and spot announcements through their affiliates. In turn, local affiliates
allow local sponsorships, spot announcements, and national spots. Cable systems allow
system (national) spots and local spots. Finally, interactive television allows (national)
spots and local spots.
Advantages: Because of its mass appeal and wide reach, television advertising is the most
cost-effective way to deliver a mass media message to a large audience. Television also
has a buzz factor with viewers talking with friends about their favorite programs. In
Copyright © 2019 Pearson Education, Inc.
301
13-9. What are trailers and how are they used as an advertising form?
13-10. How can movie advertising be used most effectively, and what are its
advantages and limitations?
Movie theaters, particularly the large chain theaters, sell time at the beginning of their
film showings for commercials, called trailers. Most of these trailers are previews
advertising upcoming films, but some are national commercials for brands, ads for local
businesses, PSAs, or other forms of sponsored programs.
Advantages: The reason trailers are valued by marketers is that they play to a captive
audience with their attention on the screen, not reading or talking to other people. The
attention level is higher for these ads than for almost any other form of commercials.
Limitations: The captive audience dimension is also the biggest disadvantage of movie
advertising because people resent the intrusion. They believe they paid for the ticket, so
they shouldn’t have to pay with their time and attention to watch commercials.
13-11. What is a website, and how does it differ from other forms of advertising?
Chapter 13: Paid Media
The internet as an advertising medium is very viable as an additional channel of
communication that will continue to have a place in the media mix. Internet sites can
attract advertisers with reasonable rates and assistance in creating an effective ad. And,
with improved metrics it is easier to accurately monitor the audiences being reached.
13-15. You are a major agency media director who has just finished a presentation to a
prospective client in convenience food marketing where you recommend increasing the
use of local radio and television advertising in spot markets. During the Q-and-A period,
a client representative says: “We know that network television viewers’ loyalty is nothing
like it was ten or even five years ago because so many people now turn to cable, VCRs,
and the Web. There are smaller audiences per program each year, yet television time
costs continue to rise. Do you still believe we should consider commercial television as a
primary medium for our company’s advertising?” Another member of the client team
questions whether broadcast is effective given the clutter on both radio and television
with long commercial pods. “Why shouldn’t we decrease our use of broadcast
advertising?” How would you answer? Develop an argument in support of either
increasing or decreasing the use of broadcast advertising for this client.
Copyright © 2019 Pearson Education, Inc.
304
13-16. Portfolio Project: You have been asked by the director of your school’s student
union to make a chart of all the traditional media serving your market to use in promoting
the center’s 50
th
anniversary events. Develop a profile for each medium giving the key
characteristics, such as type of programming (for broadcast), the type of audience
reached, the products commonly advertised, and the appropriateness of this medium as an
advertising vehicle for the center’s special celebration. At the end of your media analysis,
identify the top three that you would recommend and explain why.
Information needed to prepare the chart can be readily obtained from the various
chapters in the textbook that discuss media. In order to prepare an effective analysis,
13-17. Mini-Case Analysis: Aflac has been an award-winning campaign for years. How
important do you think the “voice of the brand” is? Why not have multiple quacking
ducks? Explain how its media use has contributed to its success. In particular, describe
how the media mix has evolved. If you were a member of the team planning the next
year’s campaign, what other media might be useful?
The duck has a voice that is essential to the brand awareness. When the duck’s voice was
silenced, the company and agency moved with lightning speed to restore it with a
Chapter 13: Paid Media
TRACE NORTH AMERICA CASE
Multicultural Advertising Media
Read the TRACE case in the Appendix before coming to class.
13-18. In what ways do traditional advertising media contribute to the “Hard to Explain,
Easy to Experience” campaign? Why?
13-19. How can online advertising be used in support of this campaign?
ADDITIONAL MATERIAL
ASSIGNMENTS
Individual Assignments
1. Research the development of the TV viewing via the internet such as Netflix and
Hulu. How has it fundamentally changed television programming? What new
challenges and opportunities does it present to advertisers? Write a 750-word paper
2. Locate and interview a radio station manager. He/she could be in AM, FM, cable,
satellite, or Web radio. Ask about the future of the industry in your market. What are
the anticipated trends? What will be different about the industry one year, five years,
and 10 years from now? What new advertising challenges and opportunities will it
bring? What is the station doing to prepare for changes? Write up your findings in a
3. Go online and visit the websites of one consumer magazine and one business
magazine. Analyze the information provided by each site regarding the target market
Think-Pair-Share
1. Together, record any 60-minute television show of your choice. Then, review the
commercials. List the sponsors and tabulate the commercials in terms of length,
number of airings, and time between commercial breaks. Taken as a whole, what
does this information tell you about clutter, intrusiveness, and irritation in television
advertising? As the consumer, what is your response to these advertisements?
Summarize your findings in a PowerPoint presentation for the class.