Counseling Chapter 8 Probation Learning Objectives After Reading This Students Should Able Describe

subject Type Homework Help
subject Pages 10
subject Words 5212
subject Authors George F. Cole, Michael D. Reisig, Todd R. Clear

Unlock document.

This document is partially blurred.
Unlock all pages and 1 million more documents.
Get Access
page-pf1
CHAPTER 8
Probation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, students should be able to:
2. Describe the two functions of probation.
4. List the major issues involved in the presentence investigation.
6. Identify the different kinds of probation conditions and explain why they are important.
8. Define evidence-based practice and discuss its importance.
10. Discuss the revocation of probation, including “technical” revocation.
LESSON PLAN
Correlated to PowerPoints
I. The History and Development of Probation.
Learning Objective 1: Describe the history and development of probation, including how it is
organized today.
A. Benefit of Clergy
2. Originally intended to protect those under protection of the church from the
king, it came to be known as the “neck verse” as it saved people from capital
punishment.
B. Judicial Reprieve
1. In England judicial reprieve became widespread in the 1800s.
2. The judge could elect to suspend either the imposition or execution of a
4. The discretionary use of such indefinite reprieves was declared unconstitutional
by the Supreme Court in 1916.
C. Recognizance
1. Boston Municipal Court Judge Peter Oxenbridge Thatcher originated the
4-7
page-pf2
2
2. The main thrust of reprieve and recognizance was to humanize the criminal law
and mitigate its harshness.
4. John Augustus was the first to formalize court leniency. He wanted to help
clients and get them to reform. He was the first to use the term probation. He also
developed these ideas:
a. A pre-sentence investigation
b. Social casework
c. Reports to the court
d. Probation revocation
D. The Modernization of Probation
1. Augustus and his followers followed the social worker model, which
2. In the 1940s, leaders in probation and other aspects of corrections began to
embrace ideas from psychology about personality and human development.
a. The medical model dominated the literature but not the practice. Still, it
remained influential until the 1960s.
b. The medical model gave way to the reintegration model. This model
assumed crime was a product of social factors such as poverty. The
approach to probation changed from counseling to service brokerage.
c. In the latter part of the 1970s, thinking about probation changed to the
model that is current today. Rehabilitation and reintegration gave way to
risk management.
d. Today, people are placed on probation in one of four ways.
i. Judges impose a sentence of probation (60 percent).
ii. Judges impose a sentence of probation that is suspended
pending good behavior (22 percent).
iii. For those already on probation, an additional probation is
imposed but suspended (9 percent).
iv. The court requires that some period of incarceration be served
prior to probation. This “split-sentence” approach has waned most
recently.
e. Judges may also impose other sentencing arrangements.
i. Modification of sentencemodified sentence of incarceration to
probation
ii. Shock incarcerationreleased after brief period of incarceration
(the shock) and placed on probation
iii. Intermittent incarcerationspends weekends or nights in jail
page-pf3
Chapter 8: Probation
What If Scenario
What if you were a judge and were given the authority to impose sentences. Under what
conditions would you sentence a person to shock incarceration and why?
3. Today, 53 percent of people on probation have been convicted of a felony.
4. Probation practices reflect the social forces of the time.
a. Today there is a growing interest in “community justice.” This is a
philosophy that emphasizes reparation to the victim and the community. It
uses problem-solving strategies instead of adversarial procedures and
seeks to increase citizen involvement in crime prevention.
Media Tool
Visit http://www.appa-net.org/eweb/
o American Probation and Parole Association
o Have students browse the site. What types of information did they discover about
probation and parole? Discuss as a class..
Class Discussion/Activity
Allow the students to partner with a classmate. They will decide upon two states and discuss the
differences in probation within one state versus another. Allow them to discuss the differences in
class while ensuring that no two states are used twice.
See Assignment 1
II. The Organization of Probation Today
Learning Objective 2: Describe the two functions of probation.
A. Originally, probation was an arm of the court (Eastern United States primarily). As it
moved west, it was placed in the executive branch.
B. Probation has merged with parole in some places. This has produced three emerging
questions.
1. Should Probation Be Centralized or Decentralized?
2. Who Should Administer Probation?
8-11
page-pf4
4
© 2019 Cengage. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or
in part.
They also claim that moving probation to the executive branch would
result in:
i. Better allocation of services.
ii. Increased interaction.
iii. Administrative coordination with corrections and allied human
services.
iv. Increased access to the legislative budget process.
v. More appropriate service priorities.
c. Proponents for judicial control argue that:
i. Probation would be more responsive to the sentencing judges’
desires.
ii. Judicial employees would produce more scrutiny of people on
probation.
iii. Morale would be higher because they would work directly with
the judge.
3. Should Probation Be Combined with Parole?
a. Probation and Parole are analogous services, both supervising people
who are serving portions of their sentences in the community.
b. Supporters of combining argue that:
i. It promotes more efficient hiring and training practices.
ii. It promotes better professionalization of community officers.
c. Others argue that:
i. There are subtle and important differences between the two
populations, and these differences call for different handling.
ii. People on probation have less criminal lifestyles.
iii. People on parole always face a more difficult time re-entering
the community.
Media Tool
Visit http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuMshrlKi5Q
o Probation officer qualities
o Discuss what it takes to work in probation. What types of qualities would rule out this
career choice?
III. The Dual Functions of Probation Investigation and Supervision
Learning Objectives 3: Discuss the purpose and content of the presentence investigation report
2. The officer then seeks to verify, clarify, and amplify the information, including
anything that has been omitted.
3. The final PSI document:
12-19
page-pf5
Chapter 8: Probation
5
a. Summarizes the findings.
b. Evaluates the findings.
c. Recommends a sentence (often).
B. Supervision begins once the person is sentenced to probation.
2. The two establish supervision goals that comply with conditions established by
the court.
3. The officer decides how to terminate probation after examining client’s
response to probation.
C. Investigation and supervision are divergent functions.
1. In preparing the PSI, the officer primarily works with human service
professionals and develops a sense of partnership with the judge.
a. Supervision is fraught with uncertainty, intangible rewards, and little
sense of accomplishment.
i. Large departments specialize their staff in order to circumvent
this problem, but this can produce inefficiencies.
ii. Supervising officer must relearn the information in the PSI.
iii. If convicted of another offense, the supervising officer should
write the PSI.
D. The Investigative Function: Preparing a presentence investigation report
1. The purpose of the presentence investigation is to help the judge select an
3. Two different goals constrain the influence of the PSI in sentencing.
a. The rehabilitative goal requires assessment of the client’s treatment
needs. i. Does the client have special problems that led to the crime?
ii. Can these be overcome by community services and careful
supervision?
4. Two circumstances constrain the influence of the PSI on sentencing.
a. Judges often seek a balance between rehabilitation and risk
5. Contents of the PSI:
1. PSIs aren’t useful unless the information is valid and reliable.
page-pf6
6
© 2019 Cengage. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or
in part.
2. Victim impact statements reflect the impact of the crime on the victim.
a. Probation officer must interview victim and in their words report
3. Recommendations: Sentencing recommendations are a controversial
aspect of the PSI because a person without authority to sentence is
suggesting what the sentence should be.
4. Disclosure: In many states, the defense does not receive a copy of the
report: Williams v. New York.
a. Sixteen states require full disclosure of the PSI.
5. Private PSIs: Private investigative firms have recently begun to provide
judges with presentence investigation reports.
a. This is often called client-specific planning.
b. In one model, the firm serves as an advocate for the defendant. In
the second, the court hires a private investigator to provide a neutral
page-pf7
Chapter 8: Probation
Class Discussion/Activity
Create a fictional account of a person with a complete history, rap sheet, and school and work
records. Divide the class into groups of three. Assign each a role as a PO consulting firm (from
the perspective of the convicted person) and private PSI author. Have each develop a PSI for this
person. Compare in class not only the differences that appear as a result of the difference of
perspective but also the differences based upon the individual performing the PSI evaluation.
See Assignment 4
IV. The Supervision Function
Learning Objective 5: Describe the dynamics that occur among the probation officer, the
person on probation, and the probation bureaucracy and Learning Objective 6: Identify the
different kinds of probation conditions and explain why they are important.
A. The Officer: Probation officers face role conflict in virtually every aspect of the job.
2. The chief conflict between the two roles arises from their use of power and
authority.
a. Power is the ability to force a person to do something he or she doesn’t
want to do. (The lack of substantive power explains why probation
3. Probation Specialists have argued that their roles can best be modeled through
motivational interviewing.
B. The Client: The client’s response has a great influence on the overall effectiveness of
probation and depends on part on his/her perception of the officer’s power as the
relationship increases.
1. Officers must decide between two styles of supervision: supportive or
controlling.
C. The Bureaucracy: This imposes both formal and informal constraints on supervision.
1. Formal constraints are the “legal conditions” of probation that are set by the
court or written into the law. There are three kinds of conditions for probation.
20
21-22
page-pf8
8
© 2019 Cengage. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or
in part.
2. Formal organizational policy constraints frequently pale compared to informal
constraints imposed by bureaucratic pressures. Three such pressures are as
follows:
a. Case control
b. Case management structure
c. Competence
What If Scenario
What if you needed to attach conditions of release to the general population of probationers?
What would you stipulate?
See Assignment 3
VI. The Effectiveness of Supervision
Learning Objective 7: Define recidivism and describe its importance to probation and Learning
1. Supervision experience, classification of convicted individuals, officers’
competence, treatment types, and policies of probation agencies contribute to the
effectiveness of recidivism more than does the caseload.
Class Discussion/Activity
Ask students to think about factors that contribute to recidivism. List the factors on the board and
discuss ways probation may be more or less effective than incarceration at targeting those factors
in a positive way.
What If Scenario
What if you were asked to work with chronic recidivists and yet maintain a positive attitude
about your job? Would you request a higher or lower case load? Why or why not?
B. Case Management Systems: “Model system” developed for case management based
on: 1. Statistical risk assessment: The use of statistically developed risk assessment
2. Systematic needs assessments: Requires evaluation according to a list of
potential needs areas.
3. Contact supervision standards: Clients are classified into supervision “levels,
23-25
page-pf9
9
4. Case planning:
5. Workload accounting: This is time studies that estimate the number of staff
needed to carry out supervision. It is a better measure than merely counting cases.
C. Evidence-Based Supervision
Learning Objective 8: Define evidence-based practice and discuss its importance.
1. Researchers have begun to systematically investigate the differences between
2. Community-based programs that follow these principles more effectively
reduce recidivism rates:
3. Overall, the evidence-based movement in community supervision has tended to
support the value of programs, when they are applied to high-risk people on
probation and use methods that are designed to reduce risk.
D. Specialized Supervision Programs
1. The needs of probationers vary dramatically.
3. Recent interest in the problem of substance abuse has increased the attention
given to people on probation with drug and alcohol problems by using new
4. Another specialized program pairs a probation officer more closely with street
police officers.
5. Specialized programs create conflict between “specialized” officers and those
who handle “regular” case officers. Regular cases become regarded as less
attractive.
E. Performance-Based Supervision: It questions about the effectiveness of community
supervision have spawned this reform.
26-27
page-pfa
1. This approach emphasizes the importance of results in setting priorities and
2. Focus on public safety is expressed in two ways.
a. Chooses supervision strategies that reflect what is known about the
effectiveness of supervision
b. Sets goals for improved supervision outcomes with their clients
D. Is Probation Effective Regardless?
1. Most studies of supervision effectiveness compare different probation
2. One recent study, however, showed a few case factors predicted new criminal
behavior yet most people showed a large and abrupt reduction in offending after
being placed on probation.
Media Tool
Visit http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QBAT07UEWug&feature=related
o GPS Supervision
o Discuss in class. What are the pros and cons of GPS monitoring?
See Assignments 2 and 5
VIII. Revocation and Termination of Probation
Learning Objective 10: Discuss the revocation of probation, including “technical” revocation.
A. Probation status is ended in one of two ways:
2. The person’s probationary status is revoked because of misbehavior.
B. The most common reason for revocation is another offense.
C. Rules violations that result in revocations are technical violations.
1. Revocation for technical violations is controversial because these are things
that are not illegal.
D. Somewhere between one-fifth and one-third of probationers do not abide by their
conditions.
E. A RAND study found much higher rates of offending:
1. More than one-third were arrested or charged with a technical violation.
2. Of these, 65 percent were arrested, while 51 percent were actually convicted.
F. It is possible probation works better in some places than others.
G. The approved practice is to handle the revocation in three stages because the client has
several due process rights. The approved practice is as follows:
1. Preliminary hearing (stage one)determine if probable cause exists for the
28-31
page-pfb
11
© 2019 Cengage. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or
in part.
2. Hearing (stage two)the facts of the allegation are heard and determined.
Person on probation has right to counsel
3. Sentencing (stage three)whether to impose confinement or amend the
probation conditions.
H. Probation in the Coming Decade
1. Two increasingly divergent types of probation:
2. Probation administrators are changing the way they want to be evaluated. The
traditional measure has been arrest rates. Some want to measure “performance
3. Probation finds itself at a crossroads.
Class Discussion/Activity
Have students discuss what factors they would consider when revoking probation of an
incarcerated individual. Would they have more leniencies for males or females? Why or why
not?
What If Scenario
What if, as a probation officer, you ignore minor violations from your probationer who has
otherwise come so far? What might the long-term consequences be?
LECTURE NOTES
The focus of this chapter is probation. Begin by reviewing what probation actually is. The
chapter explores the roots of probation in America in traces its development over time. The story
of probation offers an opportunity to explore how practices come to make their way into the
correctional system. Be sure to emphasize the relationship between social forces and correctional
practice.
page-pfc
Instructor’s Manual
12
people are placed on probation. The chapter describes the current structure of probation. The
authors ask who should administer probation and just how it ought to be utilized. Have students
discuss the issues.
This chapter divides the functions of probation into two categories: investigation and
supervision. Review each purpose and their many dimensions as highlighted in the reading. Be
sure and delve into the creation, rationale, and role of the presentence investigation. The chapter
emphasizes that sentencing recommendations in PSIs are controversial. Discuss the controversies
One of the most important parts of this chapter focuses on the complicated matter of
effectiveness of supervision. Ask them how they would define or measure effectiveness and
review the authors’ offerings.
The chapter culminates with a discussion of probation’s future. The reality of caseloads and
resources must be addressed. The chapter notes that there is a growing movement for “evidence-
based” practice in dealing with those under community supervisionprobation or parole.
KEY TERMS
Judicial reprieve
A practice under English common law whereby a judge could suspend the imposition or
execution of a sentence on condition of good behavior.
Recognizance
A formally recorded obligation to perform some act (such as keep the peace, pay a debt, or
appear in court when called) entered by a judge to permit a person who has been charged with or
page-pfd
Chapter 8: Probation
13
convicted of a crime to live in the community, often on posting a sum of money as surety, which
is forfeited by nonperformance.
Presentence Investigation (PSI)
An investigation and summary report of a convicted person’s background that helps the judge
decide on an appropriate sentence. Also known as a presentence report.
Victim impact statement
A descriptions in a PSI of the costs of the crime for the victim, including emotional and financial
losses.
Client-specific planning
Process by which private investigative firms contract with the person to conduct comprehensive
background checks and suggest to judges creative sentencing options as alternatives to
incarceration.
Power
The ability to force a person to do something he or she does not want to do.
Punitive conditions
Constraints imposed on some probation clients to increase the restrictiveness or painfulness of
probation, including fines, community service, and restitution.
Treatment conditions
Constraints imposed on some probation clients to force them to deal with a significant problem
or need, such as substance abuse.
page-pfe
Instructor’s Manual
Recidivism
The return of a former correctional client to criminal behavior, as measured by new arrests or
other problems with the law.
Evidence-based practice
Using correctional methods that have been shown to be effective by well-designed research
studies.
Technical violation
The failure to abide by the rules and conditions of probation (specified by the judge), resulting in
revocation of probation.
ASSIGNMENTS
1. Have students research statistics on probation from the Bureau of Justice Statistics or the
3. Have each student write about the terms authority and power. They should discuss their
page-pff
4. Have students watch a video regarding victim impact statements. After watching, ask
5. Have students locate drug courts within your state. Discuss how they operate, the type of
individuals who have committed a crime who use this court, and the influence this court
ANSWERS TO END-OF-CHAPTER DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Although the answers provided below will vary from student to student, the responses should
include at a minimum a discussion of the following key points.
1. Why is there so much interest in probation today? How does the use of probation affect the
corrections system? Why is it used so extensively?
2. How does the presentence investigation report affect accountability for the sentence that is
imposed?
3. How do you think the investigative and supervisory functions of probation can be most
effectively organized? What would the judges in your area say about your proposal? What
would the department of corrections say?
page-pf10
4. Given the two major tasks of probation, how should officers spend their time? How do they
actually spend their time?
5. Why might some people on probation be kept in the community after a technical violation
rather than having their probation revoked?

Trusted by Thousands of
Students

Here are what students say about us.

Copyright ©2022 All rights reserved. | CoursePaper is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university.