Break-Out Discussion #3:
Tuberculosis: A century ago, there were no effective cures for tuberculosis, and infected persons
were sequestered away to “sanitariums” to receive what treatment(s) were available, and to
await their eventual death. The disorder was often called “consumption” then, a reflection of
the manner in which the bacteria destroyed the victim’s lungs.
Questions
1. Imagine that you are sitting in church, on an airplane, or on a bus. The person next to you is
coughing incessantly. Days later you learn that this person had tuberculosis, and you were thus
exposed to this infection. How would you feel, and why? Would your answer(s) change if you
were to discover that this person had multidrug-resistant tuberculosis?
2. Does society have the right to force treatment on a person with tuberculosis? Such treatment
3. Let us assume that the infected individual in Question 1 is homeless. This means that once
treatment is started that there is a high probability that he or she will not complete the course
of treatment. Does society have the right to hold that person against their will until the infection
is cured (which might take 1–2 years)? Should they be allowed to take the medication(s) on their
own, or should medications for the treatment of tuberculosis be supervised?
REFERENCES
KEY CONCEPTS AND TERMS
Pneumonia: Acute infection of the lungs, usually caused by bacteria or fungi
Tuberculosis (TB): An infection caused by one of the genetically similar strains of
Mycobacterium tuberculosis