[number of terminal atoms (excluding H)]
(4) the number of lone-pair
of central atom pairs
number of bonding
pairs
After evaluating items 2, 3, and 4, establish the VSEPR notation and determine the molecular
shape. Use this method to predict the geometrical shapes of the following: (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Justify each of the steps in the strategy, and
explain why it yields the same results as the VSEPR method based on Lewis structures. How
does the strategy deal with multiple bonds?
Step 1 in the alternative approach is similar to the first step in the method used for drawing
Lewis structures. The only significant difference is that “electron pairs” rather than the total
number of valence electrons are counted in this alternative approach. The second step in the
alternative strategy is also similar to the second step for writing Lewis structures. By
counting the number of bonding electron pairs in the alternative method, one is effectively
working out the number of bonds present in the skeletal structure of the Lewis diagram. In
step 3, the number of electron pairs surrounding the central atom is calculated. This is
basically the same procedure as completing the octets for the terminal atoms and assigning
the remaining electrons to the central atom in the Lewis structure. Finally, in step 4 of the
alternative method, the number of lone pair electrons on the central atom is calculated. This
number, together with the result from step 3, allows one to establish the VSEPR class.
Consequently, both the alternative strategy and the Lewis diagram provide the number of
bonding electron pairs and lone pairs on the central atom for the species whose shape is
being predicted. Since the shape of the molecule or ion in the VSEPR approach is
determined solely by the number and types of electron pairs on the central atom (i.e., the
VSEPR class) both methods end up giving the same result.
Included in the “alternative strategy” is the assumption that the central atom does not form
double bonds with any of the terminal atoms. This means that in many instances, the
central atom does not possess a complete octet. The presence or absence of an octet is,
however, of no consequence to the VSEPR method because, according to the tenets of this
theory, the shape adopted by the molecule is determined solely by the number and types of
electron pairs on the central atom. Examples follow on the next two pages.