23. The concept of formal charge helped us to choose the more plausible of the Lewis structures
for
given in expressions (10.14) and (10.15). Can it similarly help us to choose a single
Lewis structure as most plausible for
Explain.
24. Show that the idea of minimizing the formal charges in a structure is at times in conflict with
the observation that compact, symmetrical structures are more commonly observed than
elongated ones with many central atoms. Use
as an illustrative example.
The intention of this question is to make the student aware of the fact that on occasion, one can
obtain a better Lewis structure “from the standpoint of formal charge minimization” by
using chain-like structures rather than the expected compact, symmetrical structures. The
two linear Lewis structures for the ClO4– (I) and (II) and a compact structure(III) are shown
below: