Chapter 6: Coaching to Connect Curriculum, Assessment & Teaching
Summary
Meeting the expectations of current early childhood state, national and professional standards
(NAEYC & NAECS/SDE, 2003) requires that teachers of our youngest children are able to
Outline
The chapter supports your growing capacity to coach teachers to
understand choices to observe, gather information, & document learning;
Learner outcomes
Students will be able to compare and contrast the characteristics of a mentor and a coach.
Coaching to
Connect
Curriculum
Assessment &
Teaching
5.
EVALUATE&
celebrate a
project
3. DEVELOP
curriculum
plan
4.
APPLY to
teaching
strategies
2.
REFLECT
make
meaning of
documentation
1.
OBSERVE
understand
assessment
choices
Suggested teaching activities
1. Introductory Mini-Lecture:
Review with participants that this book, and much of the early childhood profession, often use
the term mentor to include common strategies, activities and purposes associated with both the
_____________________________________________________________________________
Definitions: Give participants these two definitions to compare and contrast.
Mentoring: A relationship-based process between colleagues in similar professional roles, with
Coaching: A relationship-based process led by an expert with specialized and adult learning
knowledge and skills, who often serves in a different professional role than the recipient(s).
Next, draw two circles. Label one circle, “both roles” and the other circle, “coach”. Discuss
with participants and record common characteristics of mentor and coach in the “both roles”
circle. If participants do not state all of the following, add what is missing from their comments.
Real world use of the terms: mentor and coach
The most important difference in the common usage of the terms, mentor and coach, in this
author’s experience, is that coaches have special expertise in an area of early childhood
While Lutton differentiates between working with adults in similar roles (mentors) and working
with adults in different roles (coaches), in practice this distinction is often not used by
practitioners to differentiate the use of the terms.
Note: All of the following activities are centered on the role of the coach who works with an
2. OBSERVE: Coaching To Understand Assessment Choices
(A) Establish the value of observation, assessment and recordkeeping by beginning with the
suggestion for participants (who might someday be instructional coaches or who are currently
acting as coaches) to ask the following open-ended questions of early childhood care and
education teachers they know:
(B) Ask participants to guess what teachers they know might say. Then give an ‘out of class’
assignment to interview two teachers, one with more assessment experience, using the questions
here. Ask for journaling about what attitudes toward observation and assessment were conveyed
‘between the lines’ or explicitly during the conversations.
(C) Put participants into small groups and ask them to discuss this scenario:
An assistant teacher, with a year of early childhood community college courses, has asked you to
help with ways to plan curriculum for her preschool class. She wants the planned experiences to
fit the interests of the children but does not know where to start. A lead teacher in the same
classroom is excited about planning for in-depth projects and is encouraging the assistant
Now ask the participants in the small groups to discuss the following question:
How might beginning with the following questions for the assistant teacher, help to reduce her
anxiety and focus her on planning for observation before planning for curriculum and teaching?
What other ways have you encouraged teachers to observe or collect information before
planning for a project with children?
What do you already know about this group of children?
After 10 minutes, bring all the groups back to one large group and conclude by reading this
teacher recollection:
Oh yes, I remember when I thought the toddler Maureen was just a very bossy childuntil I
stopped and observed her at the sensory tub. She started dumping and pouring water into a
water wheel, when two toddler boys came to the table. As soon as she saw them, she screamed,
Share that one way a coach might let a teacher know what they already know about observation,
curriculum and teaching is to take a teacher recollection, like the previous one, and diagram the
teacher’s comments into the following categories:
Observation
Curriculum
Teaching strategies
Narrative notes on the
interactions at the toddler
Goal: Support parallel play
at the water table. Materials:
Discuss dumping and filling
with the children, and map
Journal assignment
Share these directions for a journal assignment: Observation and assessment can intimidate
early-childhood teachers who have never had formal education about its purposes, methods, and
uses. Considering the coaching principle of always starting from the strengths of the teacher,
how might you begin to engage a teacher in authentic assessment as an ongoing process to
inform his or her instruction and other program plans? Use the text for information on frequently
used assessment or observation tools and methods. See Table 6.1 in the text and comment on
what knowledge you need on assessment before coaching anyone else?
Purpose: To help participants to gain skills in dialoging with teachers about the importance of
3. REFLECT, DEVELOP AND APPLY: Coaching to make meaning of documentation
and planning for curriculum and teaching strategies
Read this scenario to participants: Imagine that you are a coach who is supporting a teacher in
the beginning of the school year, to document the words and actions of children in her program
during small group activity time. The teacher records a lot of dialogue of the children arguing
about “the rules” for putting away materials. You then ask the teacher to identify a question of
interest to both her and the children based on what she learned from her documentation. The
question she decides on is, “What are the rules in our classroom?”
Demonstrate to the large group how you would dialogue with this teacher if you were the coach
modeling how to connect observational evidence with curriculum goals and plans for learning
1) The desired result for the children is to . . .learn classroom rules;
2) The observational evidence of the children shows . . . confusion about routines and interest in
Conclude by asking the participants to discuss how they would help the teacher in this scenario
know what actual child outcomes occurred due to her learning experiences. Would she take
Purpose: To help participants understand how to join with a teacher and connect the processes
of (1) making meaning of documentation evidence to (2) planning for goals and (3) learning
experiences for children.
Activity Extension for Experienced Instructional Coaches:
Experienced coaching participants may want to use the Chapter 6Appendix A form with a
4. EVALUATE and CELEBRATE: Wrapping Up a Coaching Project
Both the teacher and the coach need to conclude projects and celebrate successes. The teacher
needs to join with the children and display, discuss and generally make visible their collective
learning though a variety of means. Ask participants to refer to the chapter or to their own
experience for ways to do this.
Documenting and Evaluating a Relationship-Based Coaching Process
Ask students to work in groups, and review this coaching documentation form. Does this look
like a form they would use during and after each visit with a teacher? What questions do they
have about the form? What changes would they make to the form so that they would use it?
Today’s focus of inquiry, discussion or other strategies used
were:
Coach linked teacher to research based concepts from:
Today’s coaching strategies
were (circle all that apply
and/or describe):
Observing teacherchild
interactions
Information gathering
Giving feedback on
observed teaching
(instructive, positive,
reflective)
Promoting reflection
through open ended
questions and probing
conversations
Demonstrating a relevant
strategy
Periodic Coaching Reflection on the Relationship Based Learning Process
To be used in reflective supervision conversations with other coaches and a supervisor.
Is the coach forming a true learning partnership based on trust with the teacher?
Did the teacher and coach negotiate and clarify their roles and responsibilities?
Are goals for teacher learning at the center of the partnership?
Purpose: To document and reflect on general relationship-based mentoring practices and
specific coaching functions.
Summary
Conclude all of the activities with this brief summary and ask the participants what is one ‘take
away’ idea that they want to implement when they act in a coaching role with another teacher.
More suggested reading and resources
Abramson, S. (2008) . Co-Inquiry: Documentation, Communication, Action. In
Voices of PractitionersCo-Inquiry Meetings for Facilitated Professional Interchange.
Espinosa, L. (2005). Curriculum and assessment considerations for young children from
culturally, linguistically, and economically diverse backgrounds. Psychology in the Schools,
42 (8): 837-853.
Gandini, L., & Goldhaber, J. (2001). Two reflections about documentation. In L. Gandini & C.
Edwards, Bambini: The Italian approach to infant/toddler care, 12445. New York:
Teachers College Press.
Jablon, J.R., Dombro, A.L., & Dichtelmiller, M.L., (2007). The Power of Observation.
Washington, DC: National Association for the Education of Young Children.
Kagan, S., Scott-Little, C., & Clifford, R. (2003). Assessing young children: What policymakers
need to know and do. In Assessing the state of state assessments: Perspectives on assessing
young children, (Eds.). Greensboro, NC: SERVE.
Lutton, A. (Ed.). (2012). Advancing the profession: NAEYC standards and guidelines for
professional development. Washington, DC: NAEYC.TI: ASSESSMENT IN HILDHOOD
McTighe, J. & Wiggins, G. (2004). Understanding by Design: professional development
workbook. Alexandria, Virginia: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
National Association for the Education of Young Children, & National Association of Early