Case Study
The Case of The Missing Information
A small manufacturing company in Oklahoma made valves and piping. In a special, urgent
job
for
some 1,000 valves, the supervisor assembled the machinists for the project and explained the
blueprints. After telling them how important the project was to the company, he then asked if
there were any questions. The long silence was concluded by the supervisor admonition to work
hard and quickly.
Later, the company leaders were inspecting the project in its early stage. To their horror, many of
the valves to this point were made incorrectly. That day, they scrapped thousands of dollars worth
of parts, not to mention the labor and delays caused.
In your opinion, what are the possibilities of what went wrong? What could you have done
if
you
were one of the employees? The supervisor? The executive leadership? The customer? The
raw materials supplier?
Class Exercises:
1. Objective: To help students understand the link between listening consequences in
communication theory.
Time:20 minutes
Directions: Ask students to write about an experience they had when someone failed to listen
a. Why might the person have done this?
b. Was this situation viewed as negative in some way?
2. Objective: How does listening affect others? Reinforce the idea of listening in everyday
living.
Time: 20 minutes
Directions: For each scenario, ask students to guess how they think the situation will end.
After a discussion, have students note positive and negative outcomes related to listening.
a. Tamisha is a responsible person who studies hard at her university. She is
a junior
who to this point has made a 4.0 GPA by listening in class and studying hard
b. A telecommunicaiton company in the Northern U.S. employs Chandler. He is
very independent and likes his job because the culture has few rules and he is
free to make most of his own decisions. Chandler also likes to get along with
3. Objective: Create a fuller understanding of listening in real life contexts.
Time: 30 minutes first class, 30 minutes second class
Directions: In one class period, have students watch a video relating to business and
professional communication or a related topic. After they watch it, develop a short summary
and what they remember the most about it. In the next class period, ask them to watch it again
and while they watch make a brief outline of all the topics covered. Then, discuss selectivity