Fraud Case 12-1
Bill and Edna had been married two years and had just reached the point where they had enough savings
to start investing. Bill’s uncle Dave told them that he had recently inherited some very rare railroad
bonds from his grandmother’s estate. He wanted to help Bill and Edna get a start in the world and would
sell them 50 of the bonds at $100 each. The bonds were dated 1873, beautifully engraved, showing a
face value of $1,000 each. Uncle Dave pointed out that “United States of America” was printed
prominently at the top and that the U.S. government had established a sinking fund to retire the old
railroad bonds. A sinking fund is a fund established for the purpose of repaying the debt. It allows the
organization (the U.S. government, in this example) to set aside money over time to retire the bonds. All
Bill and Edna needed to do was hold on to them until the government contacted them, and they would
eventually get the full $1,000 for each bond. Bill and Edna were overjoyed—until a year later when they
saw the exact same bonds for sale at a coin and stamp shop priced as “collectors’ items” for $9.95 each!
Requirements
1. If a company goes bankrupt, what happens to the bonds it issued and the investors who bought the
bonds?
2. When investing in bonds, how can you tell whether the bond issue is a legitimate transaction?
3. Is there a way to determine the relative risk of corporate bonds?
SOLUTION
Requirement 1
When a company goes bankrupt, there is a court settlement in which the remaining assets of the
Requirement 2
Stocks and bonds should normally be purchased only through a licensed securities dealer. Investors
Requirement 3
Bonds are given a grade to indicate their credit quality. Private independent rating services such as