Critical Thinking
Decision Case 11-1
Golden Bear Construction operates throughout California. The owner, Gaylan Beavers, employs 15
work crews. Construction supervisors report directly to Beavers, and the supervisors are trusted
employees. The home office staff consists of an accountant and an office manager.
Because employee turnover is high in the construction industry, supervisors hire and fire their own
crews. Supervisors notify the office of all personnel changes. Also, supervisors forward the employee
W-4 forms to the home office. Each Thursday, the supervisors submit weekly time sheets for their
crews, and the accountant prepares the payroll. At noon on Friday, the supervisors come to the office to
get paychecks for distribution to the workers at 5 p.m.
The company accountant prepares the payroll, including the paychecks. Beavers signs all paychecks.
To verify that each construction worker is a bona fide employee, the accountant matches the employee’s
endorsement signature on the back of the canceled paycheck with the signature on that employee’s W-4
form.
Requirements
1. Identify one way that a supervisor can defraud Golden Bear Construction under the present system.
2. Discuss a control feature that the company can use to safeguard against the fraud you identified in
Requirement 1.
SOLUTION
Requirement 1
A supervisor can enter a fictitious employee on a weekly time sheet, submit the time sheet to the
Requirement 2
To safeguard against the company fraud identified in Requirement 1, Beavers (or a home office
employee) should make unscheduled visits to construction sites and distribute payroll checks. If a
paycheck is payable to an employee not present to receive it, Beavers can ask other workers if the absent
person has been working on that job. If the workers say no, Beavers will have uncovered a possible
fraud.