11-40 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
ETHICAL DECISION MAKING
LO 9 DECISION CASE 11-5 INSIDE INFORMATION
1. Recognize an ethical dilemma:
The ethical issue in this case is whether or not Jim Brock acted improperly when he
2. Analyze the key elements in the situation:
1. Was anyone harmed by Brock’s actions, e.g., the parties that sold the stock at a
low price?
2. Does it matter if Brock himself profited or if some other party purchased stock
based on his knowledge?
3. Do brokers and analysts receive information about the firm that is not available to
the public? Doesn’t everyone engage in insider information?
3. List alternatives and evaluate the impact of each on those affected:
If Brock decides he has acted ethically, then he has no further responsibility in the
4. Select the best alternative:
In this case, it appears that Jim has acted unethically. He has not upheld his respon-
sibilities to his employer. Further, it is quite possible that his actions are illegal. The
SEC and state authorities have very stringent rules against someone using “insider
information” in order to obtain an advantage.
LO 5 DECISION CASE 11-6 DIVIDEND POLICY
Retained earnings represents accumulated, undistributed earnings of the company, but