Lesson Objective: Corporations and UPL? (pg. 49)
Lecture Suggestion: In the spirit of keeping the cost to the consumer at a reasonable place, it
seems logical to make an exception to the requirement of a lawyer in small-claims courts, for the
cost factor and for the sake of keeping lawyers out of small claims court. Claims for consumer
rent collection or getting your security deposit back should not be cluttered with lawyers.
However, how can the legislature differentiate between the mom and pop apartment complex
(Cleveland Bar v. Pearlman at the end of the chapter) and the huge corporation property
manager?
There are many other interesting questions in this section. In the 1980s (and any time the
economy gets bad) it became common practice to staff corporate legal departments with
paralegals to cut back on the cost of lawyers. The paralegal’s job was to coordinate outside legal
counsel with the needs of the company, not to practice law on the company’s behalf. But what
happens when the corporation (via an employee) has a question and asks the paralegal for an
answer. When that paralegal researches the answer and presents it to the corporation, isn’t that
really self-representation? This is a complex question so it’s best to demonstrate it by
contrasting a paralegal answering a question when the paralegal is not employed by the
Lesson Objective: Is just asking the court for a continuance UPL? (pg. 49)
Video Alert: In the video series, there is a segment on the paralegal “making an appearance” in
court to get a document signed (#24 Zealous Representation: Candor to the Court). The segment
is about being truthful with the court, but it also illustrates that tricky place where the paralegal
ventures into the other side of the gate.
Check Your Understanding: (pg. 50) 1. b and c; 2. a , b and d; 3. b, c and d
Lesson Objective: What’s so bad about UPL anyway? (pg. 50)
Lecture Suggestion: What are some public policy reasons for keeping the practice of law
restricted to licensed lawyers? Are those public policy reasons important enough to balance out
the lack of access to legal assistance?
Challenge Assignment: (pg. 50) Can a paralegal supervise a real estate closing in your state?
There are some bar opinions on this issue in the Extra Resources section at paralegalethics.net. It
was pretty easy to find the answer by doing a simple internet search (can a paralegal supervise a