DeVito Interpersonal Messages, 4e Instructor’s Manual
4
Vignette
A young wife leaves her house one morning to draw water from the local well; while her
husband watches from the porch. As she walks back from the well, a stranger stops her
and asks for some water. She gives him a cupful, then invites him home to dinner. He
accepts. The husband, wife, and guest have a pleasant meal together. The husband, in
a gesture of hospitality, invites the guest to spend the night—with his wife. The guest
accepts. In the morning the husband leaves early to bring home breakfast. When he
returns, he finds his wife again in bed with the visitor.
The question is: At what point in this story does the husband feel angry?
The answer is: It depends on the culture to which you belong (Hupka, 1981). In the
United States, a husband would feel rather angry at a wife who slept with a stranger;
and a wife would feel rather angry at being offered to a guest as if she were a lamb
chop. But these reactions are not universal.
A Pawnee Indian husband of the nineteenth century would have been enraged at
any man who dared to ask his wife for water.
An Ammassalik Eskimo husband finds it perfectly honorable to offer his wife to a
Comments: This report by Carole Wade and Carol Tavris (1998) illustrates that the
emotions you feel depend, in part at least, on your culture. It’s useful for introducing the
Activities for Student-Based Learning
Emotions in Song
The purpose of this activity is to analyze how emotions and emotional expression are
portrayed in popular culture, especially in songs.
In class, put students into groups of 4-5. Make a list of the key concepts from the class on
emotions, such as feeling and framing rules, obstacles to effective communication of emotion,
influences on emotions, etc. Ask the students to identify which concepts of emotion each song