Ethics Check Answers
Bypassing or False Advertising?
• J. C. Penny produced a T-shirt emblazoned with a ferocious red and blue eagle beneath
the words American Made. However, a small label inside revealed that the shirt was
made in Mexico. In response to complaints that the slogan was deceptive, a Penny
spokeswoman said that American Made referred to the person wearing the shirt, not
to the manufacturer. Was this a simple case of miscommunication?
Solution
Although J. C. Penney officials had one meaning for the slogan in mind, the T-shirt carried
another meaning. Perhaps the slogan was just a little too clever. Certainly, company officials
Busted for Buying Essays
• Macquarie University in Australia revoked the degrees of two students and prevented
others from graduating after learning that they had used an online ghost-writing
service to complete assignments. A continuing national investigation revealed that up
to 1,000 students from 16 universities had hired an online service to write their
assignments. Beyond lost degrees, what do students miss by buying essays?
Solution
Realistic students will recognize that purchased essays prevent them from developing the
KFC Names a Baby
• Kentucky Fried Chicken dangled a $11,000 contest prize to the first U.S. child born on
September 9 named Harland after founder Harland Sanders. The stunning advertising
gimmick guaranteed that many new babies would carry the KFC namesake Harland,
but only one would take home the prize. Protestors complained that parents were
turning their babies into advertisements. Was the contest unethical? By the way, the
winner, a cute little girl, was named Harland Rose, and KFC loved her.
Solution
Student responses will vary but some parents may feel they were tricked into naming their