19: Applying and Interviewing for Employment 1915
Concluding Gracefully
You can usually tell when the interviewer is trying to conclude the session. He or she may:
Ask whether you have any more questions
Check the time
negotiable or that you would expect a competitive compensation package.
If salary isn’t negotiable, look at the overall compensation and benefits package. You may find
flexibility in these areas:
A signing bonus
Profit sharing
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
Learning Objective 5: Identify the most common employment messages that follow an interview, and
explain when you would use each one.
Following up brings your name to the interviewer’s attention once again and reminds him or her that
you’re actively looking and waiting for the decision.
Any time you hear from a company during the application or interview process, be sure to respond
A message of inquiry is particularly appropriate if you’ve received a job offer from a second firm and
don’t want to accept it before you are notified by the first about their decision.
Request for a Time Extension
If you receive a job offer while other interviews are still pending, you can ask the employer for a time
extension:
19: Applying and Interviewing for Employment 1918
COMMUNICATION CHALLENGES AT VMWARE
Individual Challenge
Here are three slightly off-the-wall questions that could conceivably elicit useful responses by showing
how candidates approach problem solving:
1. Why do telephone numbers in American movies and TV shows always start with 555?
2. How old do you think I am? (This could test how observant a candidate is, not only about the
3. How many jetpacks would you need to take everyone in this office on a picnic? (This could test
the candidates ability to make numerical estimates; even if they don’t know the population of the
office, they could make a rough estimate based on the approximate size of the building. The
jetpack angle is just a red herring.)
Team Challenge
Student answers will vary, but the interview questions they come up with should acknowledge the
difficulty of evaluating soft skills in an interview. They should focus on behavioral questions to judge
TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE
19.1 How does a prospecting letter differ from an application letter sent in response to a posted
job opening?
19.2. Using the AIDA model in an application letter, you attract the reader’s attention in the first
paragraph by demonstrating your knowledge of the organization or showing how your work skills
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
19.3. When you follow up by email or telephone, you can share an additional piece of information that
19.4. Your objective during the screening stage should be to confirm your fit for the position. [LO-2]
AACSB: Written and oral communication
19.5. Behavioral interviews require candidates to use their own experiences, whereas traditional,
generic interview questions can often be answered with “canned” responses. Employers use these
19.6. In a structured interview, the employer maintains control by asking a series of preset questions in
order. The open-ended interview is less formal and has no rigid format. Instead, the interviewer
19.7. The three stages of every interview are the warm-up, the question-and-answer stage, and the
close. Of the three, the warm-up is the most important because it establishes a first and often
19.8. If an interviewer at a company where you want to work asks a question that seems too personal or
even unethical, you can (1) ask how the question is related to your credentials, (2) note that the
APPLY YOUR KNOWLEDGE
19.9. Recognize that even though the qualification did not come up in the screening interview, chances
are good that it will surface in the selection stage. Be prepared to cite specific evidence to show
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
19.10. The interviewer is likely to conclude that the applicant lacks the curiosity or the research skills
19.11. It’s important to distinguish unethical or illegal interview questions from acceptable questions
because you have a tough decision to make regarding unethical or illegal questions. You have
19.12. If your mind goes blank after an interviewer asks you a question, quickly replay the last minute or
two of the conversation in your mind to see if you can pick up the thread of what was being
PRACTICE YOUR SKILLS
19.13. Message 19.A
The letter of application will most certainly fail because of these communication problems:
The opening immediately strikes the wrong tone, as though the writer is doing the company a
favor by announcing his or her availability.
The writer does not specify which job was advertised. There may have been more than one
brand manager position.
The second sentence is presumptive, particularly given the admission of no job experience in
the third sentence.
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
19.16. Message 19.D
This letter lacks tact:
The letter of inquiry should begin with whom the candidate is and what position was applied
for; the request for a decision should also be stated up front. This writer mistakenly begins
with a me-oriented announcement that tactlessly mentions the name of another firm.
The second sentence establishes the purpose of the letter, but the undiplomatic wording
suggests that the reader intends to play the two firms against each other in some sort of
bidding contest.
19.17. Message 19.E
This letter should be expanded and reorganized using the indirect approach:
Instead of blurting out the bad news in the first sentence, the writer should begin with a
buffer. Also, the writer should identify the position in question.
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
19.18. This exercise is designed to get students thinking about the consequences of their actions and
behaviors. It may be surprising and alarming for some students to find information about
19.19 through 19.22. This is a research exercise designed to give students practice in learning about a
company prior to an interview. In addition, students are asked to use their company knowledge to
19.23. This exercise is designed to show students the difficulty of substantiating an intangible attribute.
Merely claiming that you are dependable or willing to take responsibility is not enough. The
19.24. Students’ emails should focus on one or two well-developed strengths and notable weaknesses to
substantiate their individual assessments. In addition, they should try to reframe their weaknesses
into learning experiences. An interesting question to ask the students after they’ve written their
19.25. After students complete this exercise, it might be helpful to have them exchange answers with
19-26 through 19-28. The question students must resolve is whether to mention that they will be accepting a
job with a competitor. Chances are that the current employer will find out anyway if the new
employer checks references. Since the resignation will not be good news, students should use the
indirect approachespecially since the current employer might be concerned about the person
19: Applying and Interviewing for Employment 1924
19: Applying and Interviewing for Employment 1925
CASE SOLUTIONS GUIDELINES
Here are solution guidelines for this chapter’s cases.
19.29. Media Skills: Video; Message Strategies: Employment Messages
Students will likely discover several instructive challenges with this project. Some may find it
19.30. Message Strategies: Employment Messages
19.31. Message Strategies: Employment Messages
This project combines two challenging tasks: distilling complex ideas down to 140 characters,
19.32. Message Strategies: Employment Messages
This exercise offers the dual benefits of giving students the opportunity to practice writing
19.33. Career Management: Researching Target Employers
This exercise could require a significant amount of research for students, but it helps them
19: Applying and Interviewing for Employment 1927
Copyright © 2018 Bovée and Thill LLC
employee to the company, not the individual manager. In analyzing the situation, students should
ponder the effect the letter will have on the manager. As a selfless mentor, she will be delighted
that her protégé has found a good opportunity. On the other hand, she will be seeing some of her
“handiwork” leave the company, and she’ll have a new and unwelcomed task on her to-do list
replacing the departing employee. As the case description suggests, however, the more personal
aspects of this awkward situation should be confined to the in-person conversation and not put in
the letter.
[LO-5] AACSB: Written and oral communication
ASSISTED GRADING QUESTIONS (ACCESSED ON MYBCOMMLAB)
19.39. Your application letter serves as the introduction to your résumé, creating interest in you and
19.40. Even if you don’t have any experience in a job for which you are interviewing, you can still
prepare for behavioral interview questions by reviewing your work or college experiences to