Chapter 06 – Inventory and Cost of Goods Sold
6-20
Ethical Dilemma
Diamond Computers, which is owned and operated by Dale Diamond, manufactures and sells
different types of computers. The company has reported profits every year since its inception in
2002 and has applied for a bank loan near the end of 2018 to upgrade manufacturing facilities.
These upgrades should significantly boost future productivity and profitability.
In preparing the financial statements for the year, the chief accountant, Sandy Walters,
mentions to Dale that approximately $80,000 of computer inventory has become obsolete and a
write-down of inventory should be recorded in 2018.
Dale understands that the write-down would result in a net loss being reported for company
operations in 2018. This could jeopardize the company’s application for the bank loan, which
would lead to employee layoffs. Dale is a very kind, older gentleman who cares little for his
personal wealth but who is deeply devoted to his employees’ well-being. He truly believes the
loan is necessary for the company’s sustained viability. Dale suggests Sandy wait until 2019 to
write down the inventory so that profitable financial statements can be presented to the bank this
year.
Explain how failing to record the write-down in 2018 inflates profit in that year. How would
this type of financial accounting manipulation potentially harm the bank? Can Sandy justify the
manipulation based on Dale’s kind heart for his employees?
Key Issues
• Writing off inventory reduces net income and total assets in the year of the write-off. By
delaying the write-off, the company shifts profits from the following year to the current
year, overstating current performance.
• Proper reporting vs. the long-term care of the company and its employees
Option 1: Wait to book the write-off
• Booking the write-off could be very damaging to the long-term health of the company
and its employees. Missing out on the loan could damage the profitability of future years,
leading to layoffs.
• Dale should be commended for his attentiveness to his employees’ careers.
• Accounting rules can be bent a little to help the company and employees, and five years
from now, it will not matter whether the write-off was booked in 2018 or 2019.
• As an employee, Sandy should do whatever her boss asks her to do. Any responsibility
for wrongdoing would fall on Dale.