CASE 3.3
UNITED WAY OF AMERICA
Synopsis
Unfortunately, embezzlement and other fraudulent schemes are rife in the charity “industry.”
More than any other segment of our economy, the charitable sector has been plundered by con artists
and other miscreants in recent decades. This case examines several recent embezzlement schemes
158
United Way of America—Key Facts
Case 3.3 United Way of America 159
2. William Aramony, who served as president of United Way of America for more than two
3. In 1995, Aramony was convicted of embezzling and otherwise misusing millions of dollars of
United Way funds.
5. Several other fraudulent schemes involving large charities have also been reported in recent
years.
7. A key factor contributing to the embezzlement losses suffered by United Way has been the
organization’s extremely weak and, in some cases, nonexistent internal controls.
9. Among the proposals to remedy the theft problem facing charities is that they be audited
annually by independent accounting firms.
Instructional Objectives
160 Case 3.3 United Way of America
2. To identify fundamental internal controls for cost-constrained organizations.
Suggestions for Use
Your students will likely be very familiar with the United Way and its annual fundraising
campaigns. I have found that students particularly enjoy discussing cases that revolve around
organizations with which they are very familiar.
This case is not intended to be a primer on not-for-profit audit issues, although the final case
Suggested Solutions to Case Questions
1. Not surprisingly given their nature, charities are extremely motivated to minimize their
expenses, including accounting and control-related expenses. So, the issue of “cost–effectiveness” is
particularly critical when these organizations are creating their internal control systems. Listed next
are examples of internal controls that are particularly critical for charitable organizations to adopt
and that are generally modest in terms of costs.
—Background checks for prospective employees
Case 3.3 United Way of America 161
or more of these individuals should have financial and accounting expertise and/or experience.
Quite often, local CPAs will volunteer for this service.
2. This question typically spawns a healthy debate among students. My experience has been that
most students do not believe that CPAs have a “responsibility” to provide professional services to
charities on a reduced fee basis. In discussing this issue, I typically point out that as professionals
CPAs should adopt a public service mentality—sometimes a student will raise this issue before I
3. Again, you may want to refer your students to the accounting and audit guide for not-for-profit
organizations when responding to this question. Listed next are several unique or uncommon risk
factors associated with audits of charitable organizations. [As is true for audits of any type of
organization, audit risk factors identified during the planning phase of an engagement should be
considered when developing the audit NET (nature, extent, and timing of audit tests) for the given
client.]
—Charities employ different accounting rules than for-profit entities.
—As demonstrated by this case, charities typically have weak internal control systems.
162 Case 3.3 United Way of America