ETHICAL DILEMMA
The Raintree Cosmetic Company has several loans outstanding with a local bank. The debt
agreements all contain a covenant stipulating that Raintree must maintain a current ratio of at least
0.9. Jackson Phillips, company controller, estimates that the 2016 year-end current assets and
current liabilities will be $2,100,000 and $2,400,000, respectively. These estimates provide a
current ratio of only 0.875. Violation of the debt agreement will increase Raintree’s borrowing
costs as the loans are renegotiated at higher rates.
Jackson proposes to the company president that Raintree purchase inventory of $600,000 on
credit before year-end. This will cause both current assets and current liabilities to increase by the
same amount, but the current ratio will increase to 0.9. The extra $600,000 in inventory will be
used over the later part of 2017. However, the purchase will cause warehousing costs and
financing costs to increase.
Jackson is concerned about the ethics of his proposal. What do you think?
You may wish to discuss this in class. If so, discussion should include these elements.
Step 1—The Facts:
The debt agreements for loans of Raintree Cosmetic Company require the firm to maintain a
current ratio of 0.9. If the company does not maintain the required ratio, borrowing costs on the
Step 2—The Ethical Issue and the Stakeholders:
The ethical issue or dilemma is whether the controller’s obligation to reduce the company’s
borrowing costs is greater than his obligation to provide information that is not misleading to users
of the financial statements. Users include the bank making the loans.
Step 3—Values:
Values include honesty, integrity, objectivity, loyalty to the company, and responsibility to users
of financial statements.
Step 4—Alternatives:
1. Purchase the additional $600,000 of inventory in order to maintain the current ratio at 0.9.
to the required 0.9.