The principal advantage of Plan 1 is that it involves only the issuance of common stock, which does not
require a periodic interest payment or return of principal, and a payment of preferred dividends is not
required. It is also more attractive to common shareholders than is Plan 2 or 3 if earnings before interest
and income tax is $1,050,000. In this case, it has the largest EPS ($0.35). The principal disadvantage of
Plan 1 is that it requires an additional investment by present common shareholders to retain their current
interest in the company. Also, if earnings before interest and income tax is $2,100,000, it offers the
lowest EPS ($0.70) on common stock.
The principal advantage of Plan 3 is that little additional investment would need to be made by common
shareholders for them to retain their current interest in the company. Also, it offers the largest EPS
($1.44) if earnings before interest and income tax is $2,100,000. Its principal disadvantage is that the
bonds carry a fixed annual interest charge and require the payment of principal. It also requires a
dividend payment to preferred stockholders before a common dividend
can be paid. Finally, Plan 3 provides the lowest EPS ($0.04) if earnings before interest and
income tax is $1,050,000.