14–120 Intermediate Accounting, 8/e
CASES
Communication Case 14–1
Suggested Grading Concepts and Grading Scheme:
Content (80%)
20 Convertible bonds
Entire proceeds of the bond issue should be allocated to the debt
and the related premium or discount accounts.
20 Bonds with detachable warrants
Proceeds should be allocated between debt and warrants.
Basis of allocation is their relative fair values.
Relative values are usually determined by the price at which the
respective instruments are traded in the open market.
Portion of the proceeds assigned to the warrants
should be accounted for as equity.
20 Reasons why all the proceeds of convertible bonds
should be allocated to the debt
The option is inseparable from the debt: no way to
retain one right while selling the other.
The valuation presents practical problems: would be subjective.
20 Arguments that accounting for convertible debt should be the same as
for debt issued with detachable stock purchase warrants
Convertible debt has features of both debt and shareholders’
equity, and separate recognition should be given to the
fundamental elements at the time of issuance.
Difficulties in separating the relative values of the
features are not insurmountable.
Bonus (5) Other relevant arguments not mentioned above
80–85 points
Writing (20%)
5 Terminology and tone appropriate to the audience (CFO).
6 Organization permits ease of understanding.
Introduction that states purpose.
Paragraphs separate main points.
9 English.
Word selection.
Spelling.
Grammar.
20 points