Croteau/Hoynes: Media/Society, 5th Edition
Instructor Resource
Chapter 3: Political Influence on Media
Purpose and Goals of the Chapter
It is impossible to understand the workings of the media without
knowing something about the broader social environment in which they operate. For
commercial media, especially, the government represents a major structural constraint that limits
(but in some ways also enables) the actions of the media industry. This chapter looks at how the
political world—especially the government—influences the media industry. (Note that chapter 7
examines the media’s influence on the political world. You can play these chapters off against
each other to highlight the reciprocity of relations between the media and one aspect of the social
world.)
The specific content of the chapter covers territory that has often
been in the center of public debate: regulation of the media. Most students have an awareness of
censorship and the regulation of content, but will not be familiar with the regulation of
ownership and technology. This subject matter, too, lends itself to innumerable debates and
discussions. It’s important to not get bogged down in the details of each particular controversy
(Should CDs have warning labels? Should minors be able to purchase CDs with warning
Outline of Key Chapter Themes
All parties involved support some form of government regulation of the media. The major
debates are over what kinds of regulation should exist.
Different media are regulated differently.
The FCC is a central player in regulating the media.
One key dynamic in media regulation is the debate between “free market” advocates versus
those who advocate regulating in the “public interest.”
Regulation of media applies to ownership, technology, content, and distribution.
There are numerous areas of debate about regulation, including: ownership of media outlets,
Chapter Outline
1
Croteau/Hoynes: Media/Society, 5th Edition
Instructor Resource
1. Political Influence on Media
2. The “First Freedom” and the “Public Interest”
First Amendment
Section 8, Article I of the U.S. Constitution
3. Regulation in International Perspective
European Regulation and Organization of Broadcasting
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC)
Deregulation and Competition
4. Competing Interests and the Regulation Debate
Free Market Approach versus Public Interest
Selective Deregulation
5. Regulating Ownership and Control
The Case of Pirate Radio
Broadcast Licenses and the Electromagnetic Spectrum
Regulating Ownership of Media Outlets
Changes in Media Technology
Common Carriers
Electromagnetic Spectrum and Spectrum Scarcity
Changes in Ownership Patterns
Telecommunications Act of 1996
Dual Network Rule
Regulating Content Ownership: Copyright and the Case of Music Sampling
Sampling
Fair Use
“Copyright Term Extension Act” of 1998
Regulating Ownership of Programming: The Case of “Fin-Syn” Rules
FCC regulations on TV programming (1970s)
Financial interest and syndication (“fin-syn”) rules
Forcing networks to buy programming from independent
producers
Syndication
1993 Repeal and Effects of Removal of “Fin-Syn” Rules
Network Control Increases
2
Croteau/Hoynes: Media/Society, 5th Edition
Instructor Resource
Independent Producers Squeezed Out
Regulating Ownership and Control of Technology
The Internet and “Net Neutrality”
Single-wire Monopolies
Open-access Forum
Net Neutrality
FCC Ruling
Internet Browsers
Microsoft versus the U.S Department of Justice and the European Union
Google’s Self-censorship in China
6. Regulating Media Content and Distribution
Regulating the Media Left and Right: Diversity Versus Property Rights
Regulating for Diversity: The Fairness Doctrine
The Fairness Doctrine (1949)
Forced radio stations to cover public issues
Regulating for Morality
Ratings and Warnings
Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) Rating System
oG, PG, PG-13, R, X, NC-17 Ratings and Controversies
Television Ratings
The V-Chip
Music Labels (Parental Advisory: Explicit Lyrics)
Outlawing and Controlling Distribution
Obscene Material
Pornography
Indecent Material
1973 Supreme Court Decision
The Challenge of the Internet
3
Croteau/Hoynes: Media/Society, 5th Edition
Instructor Resource
Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF)
Protect the public against fraudulent or deceptive advertising
Regulating in the National Interest
Media and the Military
Effects of Vietnam War Media Coverage
4