Sinceramente Hallmark line, which includes more than 2,500 Spanish-language cards. Hallmark
targets its African-American consumers with its Mahogany line. The Tree of Life series,
meanwhile, is aimed at Jewish customers, and in 2003, Hallmark began carrying Diwali and Eid
al-Fitr cards to appeal to its Muslim clientele. Expansion into international markets has shown
Hallmark that message appeal is largely influenced by cultural values. The Dutch audience, for
instance, tends to be more direct than Americans, while British consumers are more reserved and
less direct.
Shifting cultural demographics is only one challenge faced by Hallmark. Referring to
recent internal research, Hallmark’s CEO Donald J. Hall, Jr. says, “We’re not filling all the needs
that people have when it comes to their relationships, but we have their ‘permission’ and
opportunities to do so” (Mann 2005). Generational changes, such as the tendency of baby
boomers to purchase fewer cards than their parents, and the current popularity of e-cards have
given rise to the design of new products to entice consumers to card shop more often. Because
women buy 80 percent of all greeting cards, Hallmark works to attract today’s women,
particularly those older than 45 who no longer have children at home. The Shoebox and Fresh Ink
lines are designed to provide offbeat and entertaining options for those who prefer an alternative
to traditional sentiments. The 9/11 tragedy and the war against terrorism also revived patriotic
feelings in many people, giving rise to Hallmark products that encompass patriotic sentiments.
Hallmark knows that building good communication with friends and family, as well as
customers and business partners, means that it must design text and visual messages that
effectively convey intended meanings and emotions. The company must accurately visualize its
ever-changing audience in order to design appealing greeting cards. You, too, will need skills in
audience analysis to communicate effectively in your profession. In this chapter you will learn
various analysis skills for developing effective spoken and written messages that achieve your
desired purpose.
An extensive communications audit occurred at Hallmark Cards a few years ago. Despite
the fact that Hallmark was one of the top brand names in the United States for decades, greeting
card sales in the early and mid-90s lagged as time-conscious consumers turned to alternative
means of keeping in touch. Increased use of email, cell phone calling, and e-card options
provided viable alternatives to traditional greeting cards. In addition, a changing retail landscape
saw specialty card shops giving way to mega-retailers and deep-discount shops. Due to
Hallmark’s private ownership and highly competitive retail/intellectual property environment,
senior management had traditionally shared little with employees in terms of company finances,
business plans, and market challenges. Management’s guarded approach to communication had
resulted in declining trust levels among employees. Director of Corporate Communications Dean
Rodenbough knew that changes were needed in marketing strategy and in internal
communications.
With economic conditions showing that significant changes were imminent, Rodenbough
and other senior managers knew they had to both prepare and rally the work force. Initial focus
group research with customers, vendors, suppliers, subsidiary leadership, and employees helped
Hallmark identify behaviors that it wanted to integrate into its “new” corporate culture. A
communication audit, which took approximately 12 months to complete, resulted in the formation
of several action steps designed to assist the company in communicating openly, directly, and
honestly. According to Vicci Rodgers of The Rodgers Group, and a member of the audit team,
“Open, honest communication is becoming the norm, it’s no longer the exception, at Hallmark.”
One change implemented at Hallmark was to share with all employees the company’s
long-term vision, strategy, and financial goals. Another change was to focus more closely on
internal communication tools. Publications produced primarily for external audiences had
required extensive support from the editorial and design staff, limiting the resources available for
key internal communication programs. As part of the transformed culture, Hallmark discontinued
some of its external communication tools and repositioned its long-standing Noon News
© 2015 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a
publicly accessible website, in whole or in part.
6