Chapter 7: Business Marketing
12
Purchasing agents are often offered gifts and gratuities. Increasingly, though, companies are
restricting the amount and value of gifts that their purchasing managers can accept from vendors.
The idea is that purchasing managers should consider all qualified vendors during a buying
decision instead of only those who pass out great event tickets. This exercise asks you to
consider whether accepting various types of gifts is ethical.
Activities
1. Review the following list of common types of gifts and favors. Put a checkmark next to the
items that you think it would be acceptable for a purchasing manager to receive from a
vendor.
Advertising souvenirs Automobiles
Clothing Dinners
Discounts on personal purchases Food and liquor
Golf outings Holiday gifts
Large appliances Loans of money
Lunches Small-value appliances
Tickets (sports, theater, amusement parks, etc.) Trips to vendor plants
Vacation trips
2. Now look at your list of acceptable gifts through various lenses. Would your list change if
the purchasing manager’s buying decision involved a low-cost item (say, pens)? Why, or
why not? What if the decision involved a very expensive purchase (like a major
installation)?
3. Form a team and compare your lists. Discuss (or debate) any discrepancies.
Purpose: This exercise helps students confront the gray areas in their own ethical perceptions.
Setting It Up: Distribute the checklist above. You can have students work individually, in pairs,
or in groups to complete it. Expect some debate, as differences over what students consider
ethical are bound to arise. After students have had adequate time to determine the gifts they find
ethical, show them the grid on the next page. Discuss any differences in perceptions.
This exercise was inspired by the following Great Idea in Teaching Marketing:
Gregory B. Turner, College of Charleston
Student Ethics Versus Practitioner Ethics
This exercise can be used during a logistics or ethics segment in a basic marketing class. The
students find it quite enjoyable, and it helps promote student participation in the classroom. I