Chapter 10: Product Concepts
11
distribution and advertising, Hydrox was soon outmatched. By 1998, Hydrox sales totaled $16
million, while Oreo’s revenues were at $374 million. Hydrox has been purchased by Keebler
(subsequently purchased by Kellogg), who are trying to give the cookie a major facelift. You are
part of the Keebler team deciding what to do with the Hydrox brand.
Activities
1. Can you re-create Hydrox through a name change? What kind of brand name could go
head-to-head with Oreo? (Most people unfamiliar with Hydrox think it is a cleaning
product.) Make a list of three to five possibilities.
2. How can you package your renewed sandwich cookie to make it more attractive on the
shelf than Oreo? What about package size? Draft a brief packaging plan for the new
Hydrox (or whatever name you chose).
3. Can you modify the original formula to make something new and more competitive? Will
a brand extension work here? Why, or why not?
Purpose: To show students how important branding can be to product success. Students try to
relaunch the Hydrox cookie brand (the original chocolate sandwich cookie) by investigating
branding issues (including brand name and brand mark), determining the role of packaging, and
assessing the feasibility of brand extensions.
Setting It Up: This exercise will work best in teams or as a group project. It could also serve as
the basis for a marketing plan project.
This exercise was inspired by the following Great Idea in Teaching Marketing.
Alice Griswold, Clarke College
The Oreo Debate
This exercise can be effectively used in the chapters relating to “product” as it deals with issues
pertaining to brands (national versus private), packaging, brand loyalty, and image.
I come to class with three packages of chocolate sandwich cookies—Oreo, Hydrox, and a
private-label brand. I then ask the students which brand is their favorite. Invariably, most of the
class chooses the Oreo cookie. At this point, we launch into a taste test where each student
selects one cookie from each package and “blindly” tastes them. Most are able to identify the
Oreo cookie, but struggle to differentiate between the other two. I then ask them which is the
“original” sandwich cookie. Oreo is always the answer, which is incorrect. The Sunshine Hydrox
cookie first came on the market in 1908 and thrived until 1912 when Nabisco launched the