• Discuss the conflicted yet “codependent” relationship between PR professionals and journalists.
Show examples of obvious press releases that became newspaper or broadcast news stories.
• VNRs are particularly effective in highlighting the tensions between PR and press as well as the
tensions between government regulators (usually the FCC or FTC) and broadcasters. Show students
the “Rescue Sleep” VNR without telling them it is a VNR:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9xo0HlYXHlQ.
• Begin 25 seconds into the video, where the VNR actually begins (the first 25 seconds give
away that it’s a VNR and were not designed to be aired). End at 2:05, before the “Suggested
Tag.”
• The PR Watch report, “A First for the FCC: Fining Fake News!” (available at:
http://www.prwatch.org/news/2007/09/6478/first-fcc-fining-fake-news), documents FCC action
to fine Comcast for airing the VNR without disclosing its source.
• A 2006 Toronto Globe and Mail article reported that between 2000 and 2003, ExxonMobil Corp.
gave more than $8.6 million to think tanks, consumer groups, and policy organizations to configure a
PR assault on the idea of global warming. Despite the World Meteorological Society’s
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) consensus on climate change, ExxonMobil and a
large contingent of oil and related industries have promoted the “research” of a minority of scientists
who generally receive undisclosed amounts from industry interests to undermine the IPCC consensus
and instill disagreement (or the notion of disagreement) in the science community. The assault against
the global warming consensus is an example of what PR practitioners call “the echo chamber
technique.” A PR firm finds a scientist (often retired or past his or her prime) who says there is no
global warming to worry about. The PR firm then takes this statement and promotes it, and the
scientist goes on the road giving speeches, talking to reporters, doing press briefings, and making sure
the message is repeated over and over.
• Here are some tactics used by corporations or politicians to try to “kill” a negative story, as
documented by Alicia Mundy in the Columbia Journalism Review:
• Trying to take the story away from the reporter by threatening legal consequences if the story is
pursued, printed, or aired. Managing editors then ask themselves if the story is worth the hassle.
• Trying to control the timing or placement of the bad news such as by releasing it on Friday
afternoon or, better yet, Friday at midnight.
• Playing on the competitive nature of journalism. If information is released to one news
organization, its rival will often feel obliged to find a new angle or will ignore the scoop.
(See Alicia Mundy, “Games PR People Play; Corporate Damage Control Turns Tough,” Columbia
Journalism Review, September/October 2003, p. 10.)
• Two PR consultants, Al Ries and his daughter/consulting partner, Laura Ries, have predicted the fall
of advertising in favor of more ambitious PR campaigns. “All the recent brand successes have been
basically PR successes, not advertising successes,” they wrote in a 2003 Ad Age article. They name
Red Bull, Harry Potter, JetBlue, Linux, Palm, Starbucks, PlayStation, and Microsoft’s Xbox as
examples of products that relied almost solely on public relations to get them into the public
consciousness. “No new brand is as clearly a PR success as Botox. Imagine trying to use advertising
to introduce a new product with the theme ‘Let us inject a toxin made from the bacteria that causes
botulism into your forehead to cure your wrinkles.’ Yet PR did just that. In eight years, with no
advertising at all, Botox became a $300 million brand,” they wrote. The Ries’ strategy is to first use
PR to change minds and then turn to advertising to keep people from changing their minds back.
• The “Will it blend?” campaign, launched by BlendTec in 2006, is a mixture of PR and advertising.
BlendTec created a series of videos, shot for under $100, that featured a nerdy/cheesy, science-guy
host putting unlikely objects into the BlendTec blender: a video camera, golf balls, an iPod, marbles,
glow sticks, and so on. BlendTec released the videos on YouTube hoping to generate a social media
marketing buzz. The result was an enormously successful viral video campaign that, according to one
media analyst, “is the stuff of marketing legend, like Apple’s ‘1984 Macintosh’ campaign or Wendy’s