Is It Ethical for Zappos to Fix the Grammar and Spelling in Its Customers’ Reviews?
Estimates suggest that Zappos, the Internet’s most popular site for quality footwear, has spent
hundreds of thousands of dollars fixing more than a million of its customers’ online reviews. Does
this repair alter the authenticity of the reviews?
Correcting a reviewer’s grammar may not change the content of a review, but it certainly changes the
nonverbal message sent to a reader. If a writer cannot spell awesome, readers tend to devalue that
writer’s review of, let’s say, trail running shoes. Professor Panos Ipeirotis, who studies consumer reviews
on the Internet, asserts that well-written reviews help sell products, even when the write-ups are negative.
[Agger, M. 2011, May 10. Awsum shoes? Slate.com.] This may explain why Zappos has gone to so much
trouble to correct its customers’ reviews. Correctness definitely counts. Well-written reviews seem
trustworthy because of the favorable impression we have of the writer. Reviews littered with misspelling,
capricious punctuation, and Internet slang drain the review’s authority. However, fixing errors changes the
reader’s perception of the review and borders on unethical marketing behavior.
Critical Thinking Answers
1. Molly, a twenty-three-year-old college graduate with a 3.5 GPA, was hired as an administrative
assistant. She was a fast learner on all the software, but her supervisor had to help her with
punctuation. On the ninth day of her job, she resigned, saying: “I just don’t think this job is a
good fit. Commas, semicolons, spelling, typos—those kinds of things just aren’t all that
important to me. They just don’t matter.” For what kind of job is Molly qualified?
By refusing to develop fundamental language skills or to recognize their importance, Molly is limiting
2. Why is audience analysis so important in the selection of the direct or indirect strategy of
organization for a business message?
Audience analysis is important because it helps the writer decide whether the receiver will react
positively or negatively to the message. Help your students develop the habit of always thinking of
3. How are speakers different from writers in the way they emphasize ideas?
Speakers have an array of nonverbal cues they can use to express many more emotions and
nuances of meaning than are possible in writing. A speaker can raise an eyebrow, lower her voice,
utter a sigh, wipe her hand across her brow, or tap her fingers on the table. Each of these cues
4. Why are short sentences and short paragraphs appropriate for business communication?
Business readers want to see the main idea immediately. Short sentences and paragraphs convey
ideas quickly and are more readable than longer ones. In addition, today’s short-form digital