Criterial Thinking Cases
12.1 The Madsen’s Problem: What to Do with All That Money?
A couple in their early 30s, Rodney and Carly Madsen recently inherited $90,000 from a
relative. Charles earns a comfortable income as a sales manager for System Analytics, Inc.,
and Carly does equally well as an attorney with a major law firm. Because they have no
children and don’t need the money, they’ve decided to invest all of the inheritance in
stocks, bonds, and perhaps even some money market instruments. However, because
they’re not very familiar with the market, they turn to you for help.
Critical Thinking Questions
1. What kind of investment approach do you think the Madsen should adopt—that is,
should they be conservative with their money or aggressive? Explain.
The Madsens do not have a specific goal that they are investing to reach. Also, they do not
appear to want to spend time managing the investments. They also only have $90,000 so a wide
array of stock portfolio is not feasible. While it is the topic of chapter 13, I would suggest two
If they want to spend some time investing the funds, they can select three so stocks and buy and
2. What kind of stocks do you think the Madsen should invest in? How important is current
income (i.e., dividends or interest income) to them? Should they be putting any of their
money into bonds? Explain.
As above, if they invest in stocks, I would suggest some utility stock and health care stock.
3. Construct an investment portfolio that you feel would be right for the Madsen and invest
the full $90,000. Put actual stocks, bonds, and/or convertible securities in the portfolio; you
may also put up to one-third of the money into short-term securities such as CDs, Treasury
bills, money funds, or MMDAs. Select any securities you want, so long as you feel they’d be
suitable for the Madsen. Make sure that the portfolio consists of six or more different
securities, and use the latest issue of The Wall Street Journal or an online source such as
http://finance.yahoo.com to determine the market prices of the securities you select. Show
the amount invested in each security along with the amount of current income (from
dividends and/or interest) that will be generated from the investments. Briefly explain why
you selected these particular securities for the Madsen’ portfolio.
The students like many investors, will most likely look at the past returns and assume they will
continue in the future. It would be great if the students could have the opportunity to invest part