▪ Ask them to design a short survey to find out how much customers are willing to pay for a ride in a
transporter (or to purchase the futuristic product of their choice).
▪ How much confidence would they have in the answers they got? Why?
A common conclusion is likely to be that customer-oriented pricing is a difficult strategy to employ for a
revolutionary product like this, because customers have neither the experience nor (in many cases) a
good reference point to use to determine the value provided. One thing the marketer can do that may
help is to suggest a reference by comparing the new product to something more familiar to the consumer
that serves a similar purpose. For example, in the case of the transporter, one comparison would be to air
travel, emphasizing the advantages of instant transportation that add value.
U.S. Cellular: Matching Price with Perceived Value
▪ Activity Type: Video Case
▪ Learning Objectives: 14-01, 14-02, 14-03, 14-05
▪ Difficulty: Medium
▪ Activity Summary: This case discusses pricing strategy at U.S. Cellular. After the video ends,
students are asked questions about the video and related course concepts.
Activity
▪ Introduction: U.S. Cellular is a mid-range service provider in the highly competitive cell phone
market. In this market, Verizon Wireless and AT&T are the major players. To compete, smaller firms
like U.S. Cellular must find ways to deliver greater value to their customers. However, price has a
major impact on value perceptions. In turn, value perceptions influence pricing. In 2010, U.S. Cellular
created a pricing strategy known as The Belief Plan, but it confused customers. They perceived that
the price was set too high for the value it offered. This forced U.S. Cellular to rethink its strategy.
Watch the following video to examine the many factors U.S. Cellular needs to consider when setting
price.
▪ Concept Review: Setting price is a formidable challenge for marketers. Knowing how customers
perceive value in the product or service is only one component of the five Cs of pricing. A firm’s
overall pricing orientation will depend on the company objectives. Marketers must consider
competitors and their strategies. Markets are characterized by four types of competition: monopoly,
oligopoly, pure competition, and monopolistic competition. Costs are a major element in setting price.
Channel members must also be accounted for. Prices change, and when changing prices, marketers
must be aware of the price elasticity of demand for their particular product or service. When price is
set correctly, firms reap substantial rewards. But when the price is wrong, customer response will be
swift and severe.
▪ Video: The video is presented to the student below the introductory information. The video plays
embedded on the page, after which questions are presented.
Follow-Up Activities
Discussion: Companies need to be careful when adopting innovative pricing plans; as the video case
shows, customers can become confused and be unable to see the value being offered.
One fairly recent example of a company that made this mistake is J.C. Penney. The first part of this article
offers a good summary of the pricing plan and consumers’ response: