Real World Case 9–8
Requirement 1
Inventories are valued using the retail first-in, first-out method for goods in
Requirement 2
The company uses the Producer Price Index in applying the dollar-value LIFO
Requirement 3
The disclosure note states that the current cost of inventories exceeded the
LIFO cost for pharmacy department inventories by approximately $47.5 million at
Therefore, cost of goods sold for the year ended January 30, 2016, would have
Requirement 4
($ in thousands)
Case 9–8 (concluded)
Requirement 5
For changes not involving LIFO or changes from the LIFO method to another,
the event is accounted for as a normal change in accounting principle. In general,
we report voluntary changes in accounting principles retrospectively. This means
revising all previous periods’ financial statements as if the new method were used
Communication Case 9–9
Requirement 1
Change in Inventory Method
During 2018, the Company changed the method of valuing its inventories from
the first-in, first-out (FIFO) method, to the last-in, first-out (LIFO) method,
determined by the retail method. To estimate the effects of changing retail
prices on inventories, the Company utilizes internally developed price indexes.
The Company believes that the change to the LIFO method provides a
Note: Because cost of goods sold would have been $22 million lower if the
change had not been made, income before tax would have been $22
million higher, and net income would have been $13.2 million higher ($22
million multiplied by 60% [1 – .40]).
Requirement 2
It usually is impracticable to calculate the cumulative effect of a change to
LIFO. To do so would require assumptions as to when specific LIFO inventory
Judgment Case 9–10
Despite the self-correcting feature of certain inventory errors, the errors cause
the financial statements of the year of the error as well as the financial statements
If a material inventory error is discovered in an accounting period subsequent
to the period in which the error is made, previous years’ financial statements that
were incorrect as a result of the error are retrospectively restated to reflect the
Ethics Case 9–11
Requirement 1
Bonuses will be negatively affected because if the error is corrected, a lower
Requirement 2
It will be reported as a prior period adjustment to the beginning retained
earnings balance for the year beginning July 1, 2018. Financial statements for the
Requirement 3
Ethical Dilemma:
Should John recognize his obligation to disclose the inventory error to
Analysis Case 9–12
Purchases are recorded at market price when market price is lower than the
agreed upon contract price, and a loss is recognized for the difference between
In this case, the contract price of $0.80 per gallon is compared to the market
price at December 31. If market is less than $0.80, an estimated loss is recognized
As the heating oil is purchased in 2019, if an estimated loss is recorded at
Target Case
Requirement 1
Requirement 2
The use of RIM will result in inventory being valued at the lower of cost or
Requirement 3
Activity under this program is included in sales and cost of sales in the
Air France-KLM Case
No. Both U.S. GAAP and IFRS require inventory to be valued at the lower of
cost and net realizable value.