You can also do this on most calculators. For the TI-BA-II+,
press 2nd I Conv (above the number 2), enter 18 for the NOM
rate (do not forget to press enter), press the up arrow to go to
C/Y and enter 12, press the up arrow to go to EFF and press
CPT = 19.56%. Most other financial calculators can do this as
well.
Lecture Tip: Here is a way to drive the point of this section home. Ask
how many students have taken out a car loan. Now ask one of
them what annual interest rate s/he is paying on the loan.
Students will typically quote the loan in terms of the APR.
Point out that, since payments are made monthly, the effective
rate is actually more than the rate s/he just quoted, and
demonstrate the calculation of the EAR.
Ethics Note: Rent-to-own agreements and tax refund loans have a lot in
common. Because of the structure of the contracts, they do not
have to provide information on interest rates. However, when
you work out the rates implied in the contracts, they can be
extraordinarily high. It is worthwhile to encourage students to
use caution (and their newfound knowledge of time value!)
when considering these situations.
Example: Suppose you are in a hurry to get your income tax refund. If you
mail your tax return, you will receive your refund in 3 weeks. If
you file the return electronically through a tax service, you can
get the estimated refund tomorrow. The service subtracts a $50
fee and pays you the remaining expected refund. The actual
refund is then mailed to the preparation service. Assume you
expect to get a refund of $978. What is the APR with weekly
compounding? What is the EAR? How large does the refund
have to be for the APR to be 15%?
Using a financial calculator to find the APR: PV = 978 – 50 =
928; FV = -978; N = 3 weeks; CPT I/Y = 1.765% per week;
APR = 1.765 (52 weeks per year) = 91.76%!!!
Compute the EAR = (1.01765)52 – 1 = 148.38%!!!!
You would be better off taking a cash advance on your credit card and
paying it off when the refund check comes, even if you have the
most expensive card available.
Refund (net of $50) needed for a 15% APR:
PV + 50 = PV(1 + (.15/52))3
PV = $5,761.14