24
CHAPTER 4
Diatonic Chords in Major and Minor Keys
This chapter begins by attempting to dispel the notion, so often held by students, that a tonal composer chooses from
a menu of three scales before beginning a piece in the minor mode. The fact is, of course, that diatonic minor mode
music is more complicated than diatonic music in the major mode because of the variability of § and ¶. It is fair to
say that in minor most melodic pitches conform to the melodic minor scale and most harmonic pitches belong to the
harmonic minor scale, but exceptions are so common as to render such a “rule” useless.
These complications are encountered when triads and seventh chords in minor are presented. Instead of following
the simpler but misleading system of forcing chords to conform to the harmonic minor scale, we include as norms
three chords from outside of that scale: III, i7, and IIIM7.
Class activities should include a great deal of drill, especially involving triads. Brain twisters like “F is the 5th of a
vi chord in what major key?” and “F# is the bass note of a Vt in what minor key?” will challenge even the best
students and help to develop skills essential for analysis.
Answers to Selected Exercises
Exercise 4-1
A. 1. Cm 2. Bm 3. D#0 4. Bb/F 5. C 6. Em/G 7. Fm/C
vi iv vii0 IIIw V vi6 ivw
B. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
ab: 20 Cb: 70 G: 70 c: III Fm: ii e: VI F: iii
C. 1. I Vq IVq V Iq vii0q I IV
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8