Multinational Financial Management: An Overview 4
35. Valuation of an MNC. Odessa Co., Midland Co., and Roswell Co. are U.S. firms in the same
industry and have the same valuation as of yesterday, based on the present value of future cash flows
of each company. Odessa Co. obtains a large amount of its supplies invoiced in euros from European
countries, and all of its sales are invoiced in dollars. Midland has a large subsidiary in Europe that
does all of its business in euros and remits profits to the U.S. parent every year. Roswell Co. has no
international business. Suppose an event occurs that you believe will cause a substantial depreciation
of the euro against the dollar over time, but assume this event will not change the business operations
of the firms mentioned. Which firm will have the highest valuation based on your expectations?
Briefly explain.
ANSWER
36. Impact of Uncertainty on an MNC’s Valuation. Assume that Alpine Co. is a U.S. firm that has
direct foreign investment in Brazil as a result establishing a subsidiary there. Political conditions have
changed in Brazil, but the best guess by investors regarding the future annual cash flows for Alpine
Co. has not changed despite the uncertainty surrounding those estimates. In other words, the
distribution of possible outcomes above and below the best guess has widened. Would this change in
uncertainty cause the prevailing value of Alpine Co. to increase, decrease, or remain unchanged?
Briefly explain.
ANSWER: The increase in uncertainty surrounding cash flows would cause the prevailing value of
37. Exposure of MNC Cash Flows.
a. Rochester Co. is a U.S. firm that has a language institute in France. This institute attracts
Americans who want to learn the French language. Rochester Co. charges tuition to the American
students in dollars. It expects that its dollar revenue from charging tuition will be stable over each of
the next several years. Rochester’s total expenses for this business project are as follows. It rents a
facility in Paris, and makes a large rent payment each month in euros. It also hires several French
citizens as full-time instructors, and pays their salary in euros. Rochester Co. expects that its
euro-denominated expenses will be stable over each of the next several years. If the euro appreciates
against the dollar over time, should this have a favorable effect, unfavorable effect, or no effect on the
value of Rochester Co.? Briefly explain.
b. Rochester considers a new project in which it would also attract people from Spain, and the
institute in France would teach them the French language; tuition would be charged in euros. The
expenses for this project would be about the same as those for the one just described for American
students. Assume that euros to be generated by this project would be stable over the next several
years. Assume that this project is about the same size as the project for American students. For either
project, the expected annual revenue is just slightly larger than the expected annual expenses. Is the
valuation of net cash flows subject to a higher degree of exchange rate risk for this project or for the
project for American students? Briefly explain.
© 2015 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as
permitted in a license distributed with a certain product or service or otherwise on a password-protected website for classroom use.