5. Explain to Damon the rationale for choosing ETFs over mutual funds.
13.2 Nichole Ponders Mutual Funds
Nichole Whiting is the director of a major charitable organization in Charlotte, North
Carolina. A single mother of one young child, she earns what could best be described as a
modest income. Because charitable organizations aren’t known for their generous
retirement programs, Nichole has decided it would be best for her to do a little investing on
her own. She’d like to set up a program to supplement her employer’s retirement program
and, at the same time, provide some funds for her child’s college education (which is still 12
years away). Although her income is modest, Nichole believes that with careful planning,
she could probably invest about $250 a quarter, and she hopes to increase this amount over
time. Nichole now has about $15,000 in a bank savings account, which she’s willing to use
to kick off this program. In view of her investment objectives, she isn’t interested in taking
a lot of risk. Because her knowledge of investments extends no further than savings
accounts, series EE bonds, and a little bit about mutual funds, she approaches you for some
investment advice.
Critical Thinking Questions
1. In view of Nichole’s long-term investment goals, do you think mutual funds or ETFs are
the more appropriate investment vehicle for her?
2. Do you think that Nichole should use her $15,000 savings to start a mutual fund or an
ETF investment program?
3. What type of mutual fund or ETF investment program would you set up for Nichole? In
your answer, discuss the types of funds you’d consider, the investment objectives you’d set,
and any investment services (such as withdrawal plans) you’d seek. Would taxes be an
important consideration in your investment advice? Explain.