3. Q: What is the name of the grouping of 55 nations across the continent of Africa?
A: A group of 55 nations on the African continent joined forces in 2002 to create the African
Union.
Ethical Challenge
The Caribbean nations do not participate in NAFTA and CAFTA-DR. Many people in southern U.S.
states complain that NAFTA and CAFTA-DR are unfair to their extended families living on the
Caribbean islands. Some experts argue that the term free trade agreement is misleading. They say
these agreements are really “preferential trade agreements” that offer free trade only to members and
relative protection against nonmembers. They argue that these trade agreements have cost jobs,
market share, and income from apparel factories in Jamaica to sugar cane fields in Trinidad.
8-5 Given the impact on nonmembers, do you think such trade agreements are ethical?
A: Student responses will vary. The key issues that could be included in their review should
address whether the trade agreement pay enough attention to the quality of the jobs? What
8-6 Why do you think the Caribbean islands are not part of NAFTA or CAFT-DR?
A: Student responses will vary. However, some Caribbean nations may be excluded because
rules and requirements of being a member of the free trade agreement.
8-7 What arguments would you make for including the Caribbean in the expansion of NAFTA or
CAFTA-DR?
A: One question to be addressed here is the responsibility that the United States has to its
neighbors. Certainly, many Caribbean nations have strong economic and cultural ties to the
United States. The “free trade” versus “preferential trade” ethical debate is nothing new. There
Teaming Up
Debate Project. Two groups of four students each will debate the merits of extending NAFTA to more
advanced levels of economic (and political) integration. After the first student from each side has
spoken, the second student will question the opponent’s arguments, looking for holes and
inconsistencies. The third student will attempt to answer these arguments. A fourth student will present
a summary of each side’s arguments. Finally, the class will vote to determine which team offered the
more compelling argument.
A: There would be many economic and political obstacles in expanding NAFTA to more advanced
levels of integration and to include other countries. First, there is the problem of unequal levels of