Fraud Case 9-1
Jim Reed manages a fleet of utility trucks for a rural county government. He’s been in his job for 30
years, and he knows where the angles are. He makes sure that when new trucks are purchased, the
residual value is set as low as possible. Then, when they become fully depreciated, they are sold off by
the county at residual value. Jim makes sure his buddies in the construction business are first in line for
the bargain sales, and they make sure he gets a little something back. Recently, a new county
commissioner was elected with vows to cut expenses for the taxpayers. Unlike other commissioners, this
man has a business degree, and he is coming to visit Jim tomorrow.
Requirements
1. When a business sells a fully depreciated asset for its residual value, is a gain or loss recognized?
2. How do businesses determine what residual values to use for their various assets? Are there “hard and
fast” rules for residual values?
3. How would an organization prevent the kind of fraud depicted here?
SOLUTION
Financial Statement Case 9-1
View a link to Target Corporation’s Fiscal 2015 annual report at http://www.pearsonhighered.com/Horngren.
Refer to the Target Corporation financial statements, including Notes 14 and 15. Answer the following questions.
Requirements
1. Which depreciation method does Target Corporation use for reporting in the financial statements? What type
of depreciation method does the company probably use for income tax purposes?