Students’ answers will vary. An interesting infographic is available at Irfan Ahmad, “How
Non-Sexy Businesses Rock On Social Media,” socialmedia today, March 2, 2014, available
at:
Marketing Ethics: Unrealistic Bodies
With more than a third of American children and adolescents overweight, you would think that
Mattel’s slender Barbie doll would be a good role model for little girls. Not so, according to
some critics. If Barbie was a real woman, she would have less than 17 percent body fat, a neck
too thin to hold her head up, a waist too small to house a full liver and intestines, and ankles and
feet too tiny to walk. One group of researchers estimated the likelihood of a woman having
Barbie’s body at one in 100,000. Yet some women strive for impossible bodies, with more than
20 million suffering from eating disorders such as anorexia and bulimia. Other research has
shown that forty to sixty percent of preadolescent girls are concerned about their weight, and
almost 70 percent of elementary-aged girls who read magazines say the pictures of thin models
influence their perceptions of an ideal weight. Statistics like these cause consumer advocacy
groups such as the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood (CCFC) to call for action,
especially when targeting young girls. For example, the CCFC is concerned about Mattel’s
Barbie Be Anything, Do Everything partnership with the Girl Scouts, in which Daisy and
Brownie scouts (that is, kindergarten through third-graders) can play an interactive game on the
Girl Scouts’ Web site and earn Barbie participation badges to wear on their uniforms.
6.11. Do you think it is wrong for Mattel and other doll manufacturers to market dolls with
unrealistic body proportions to young girls? Explain why you think that way. Discuss
other examples of marketers targeting females with unrealistic body concepts. (AACSB:
Communication; Ethical Reasoning)
Answer:
6.12. Give an example of a company that is countering this trend by offering more realistic
dolls for young girls. (AACSB: Communication; Reflective Thinking)
Answer:
One example that stands out is the American Girl company (www.americangirl.com), also a
Mattel brand. This company offers several dolls for girls 8-12 years old that are