Chapter 36
corporations would reach unlimited levels.
Case 36.1 Shareholder’s Limited Liability: Menendez v. O’Niell
986 So.2d 255 (2008), Court of Appeal of Louisiana
Facts: A vehicle driven by Michael O’Niell crashed while traveling on Louisiana Highway 30.
Judgment asserting that as a shareholder of Triumvirate Corporation, he was not liable for the
corporation’s debts. The trial court granted summary judgment to Fraioli and dismissed him as a
defendant in the case. Savoy appealed.
Issue: Is Fraioli personally liable for the debts of Triumvirate, a corporation of which he is the
sole shareholder?
Ethics Questions: The law permits shareholders to avoid personal liability for the debts of the
corporation they own because corporations are separate legal entities and they are liable for their
own debts and obligations. It will not be practically possible for Fraioli to check the age of each
of his customers before serving them liquor. Also, on the day of the accident, Fraioli was not
Triumvirate from its liability.
Public and Private Corporations – Government-owned corporations (or public corporations)
profit to members, directors, or officers.
Publicly Held and Closely Held Corporations – Publicly held corporations have many
shareholders and are usually traded on stock exchanges. Closely held corporations have shares
that are owned by few shareholders. In the latter, there is usually a buy-and-sell agreement which
Professional Corporations – These corporations are formed by licensed professionals, and are
identified by P.C., P.A., or S.C. Shareholders of professional corporations are often called
members. Generally, only licensed professionals may become members.