978-0134004006 Chapter 2 Lecture Note

subject Type Homework Help
subject Pages 9
subject Words 3917
subject Authors Henry R. Cheeseman

Unlock document.

This document is partially blurred.
Unlock all pages and 1 million more documents.
Get Access
page-pf1
9
Voltaire
I. Teacher to Teacher Dialogue
preconceptions.
Among these is the average undergraduate’s notion of how trials are conducted and the role
of attorneys in that process. Invariably these perceptions center on popular television series such
as “Law and Order” and “Court TV. This is not all bad. Current media focus on numerous law-
related issues has generated a whole new wave of public interest in the workings of our legal
Trials are long, tedious, emotionally, and financially draining processes for all parties concerned.
In many ways, a trial represents a failure by the parties to reach some sort of satisfactory solution
of the issue beforehand. Rarely do the parties actually want to go through a labyrinth of
pleadings, motions, and the like, feeling all the while totally dependent on the sometimes
stage and how even fewer of those are actually reported in the National Reporter System.
Additionally, a fair amount of time should be spent reviewing the growing trend toward
alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms. Personal experience examples might be helpful
in illustrating the growing trends toward ADR. To complete the cycle, we can then proceed to
COURTS
AND JURISDICTION
2
page-pf2
Chapter 2
10
II. Chapter Objectives
1. Describe state court systems.
2. Describe the federal court system.
III. Key Question Checklist
If the dispute or controversy needs to be resolved in a court of law, which court has
jurisdiction?
Once jurisdiction is established, was the proper sequence of pretrial steps taken?
Was the trial sequence properly followed?
After the trial is completed, are any appeals from the decision applicable?
IV. Text Materials
One objective of this chapter is to familiarize students with the role of the major players in those
events.
The federal court system and the court systems of the 50 states and the District of Columbia are
State Court Systems
Limited-Jurisdiction Trial Court Inferior trials like traffic courts, juvenile courts, justice-of-
General-Jurisdiction Trial Court Courts of Record keep a record of the testimony and
Intermediate Appellate Court Courts of Appeal hear appeals from trial courts, reviewing
Highest State Court State supreme courts hear appeals from intermediate state courts and
Contemporary Environment: Delaware Courts Specialize in Hearing Business Disputes
Delaware has created a special Chancery Court to decide business litigation, with a reputation for
handling corporate matters. Delaware’s laws also tend to favor corporate management, so
page-pf3
Courts and Jurisdiction
11
Federal Court System
Special Federal Courts There are six courts of limited jurisdiction: the U.S. tax court, federal
U.S. District Courts These are the federal court system’s 94 trial courts of general jurisdiction.
U.S. Courts of Appeal These are the federal court system’s 13 intermediate appellate courts.
Supreme Court of the United States
The Supreme Court is composed of nine justices who are nominated by the President and
Contemporary Environment: The Process of Choosing a U.S. Supreme Court Justice
The President appoints Supreme Court justices, with the advice and consent of the Senate
Jurisdiction of the U.S. Supreme Court The Supreme Court hears appeals from the federal
district courts and from the highest state courts. Legal briefs are filed, oral arguments are made,
Decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court Congress has established the rules for the mandatory
appellate review by the Supreme Court, which may also elect to hear cases at its discretion.
Majority Decision Decisions by the Supreme Court are considered majority decisions
Plurality Decision A plurality decision is when the majority of the justices agree on the
Tie Decision In this case, the winner in the lower court prevails. This does not serve as
precedent.
Concurring Opinion When a justice agrees with the outcome of the majority, but not
page-pf4
Chapter 2
12
opinion.
Contemporary Environment: “I’ll Take You to the U.S. Supreme Court!”
This discusses the process necessary to win a review by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Jurisdiction of Federal Courts
questions with no dollar amount limit.
Diversity of Citizenship The federal courts have jurisdiction to hear cases involving diversity
Florida
Facts: Chanel is an international cosmetics company, which averred that a Chinese resident
Issue: Chanel asked the court for permission to serve the defendant electronically.
will defend in the case.
Jurisdiction of State Courts State courts hear cases that the federal courts do not have the
jurisdiction to hear.
Standing to Sue, Jurisdiction, and Venue
Standing to Sue The plaintiff must have a stake in the outcome of the lawsuit.
Defendants disputing the jurisdiction of a court may make a special appearance to argue their
case, and cannot be served while making this appearance.
page-pf5
Courts and Jurisdiction
13
minimum contact with the state.
Landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case Minimum Contacts
International Shoe Company v. State of Washington
International Shoe had salespeople that sold shoes door-to-door within the state of Washington,
International, which appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court ruled that
International had neither casual nor irregular contacts within the state, and was, therefore, subject
to in personam jurisdiction and service upon one of their agents, based on their “minimum
contacts” within the state. The Supreme Court clearly stated that the Due P/rocess Clause permits
substantial justice.”
Critical Legal Thinking Questions: There are firmly established standards developed through
case law, which allow a court to determine when minimum contact has been made with a state.
Case 2.2 Long Arm Statute: MacDermid, Inc. v. Deiter
Second Circuit
Facts: Prior to her employment termination, the defendant took proprietary property from her
employer who in turn sued her to get it back.
Issue: Does the district court have personal jurisdiction over the defendant?
Decision: Yes
In Rem Jurisdiction Courts may have jurisdiction over property found within the state, based
on in rem (over the thing) jurisdiction.
Quasi In Rem Jurisdiction Attachment jurisdiction occurs when a plaintiff who has obtained a
Venue The court with the jurisdiction that is located closest to where the incident occurred or
where the parties live should hear the lawsuit.
Pretrial publicity may prejudice jurors and may lead to a request for a change of venue in order to
get a more impartial jury. Forum shopping is the process of looking for a more favorable court
Forum-Selection and Choice-of-Law Clauses Because many business agreements are formed
between people from different states and different countries, many contracts have clauses that
page-pf6
Chapter 2
14
2.3 Forum-Selection Clause: Fteja v. Facebook, Inc.
Southern District of New York
Facts: The plaintiff contends that Facebook committed religious discrimination in closing his
Facebook account. Facebook filed a motion to have the suit moved to federal court, the Northern
District of California, based on a clause in the click wrap agreement the plaintiff signed when he
opened his account.
Jurisdiction in Cyber Space
Today, with the advent of the Internet and the ability of persons and businesses to reach millions
of people in other states electronically, particularly through websites, modern issues arise as to
International Law: Judicial System of Japan
There is very little litigation in Japan when compared to the United States. A primary reason for
the difference is cultural because Japan nurtures the attitude that confrontation should be avoided.
Other reasons include the high cost that must be borne by plaintiffs who want to file a lawsuit.
V. Key Terms and Concepts
Article III of the U.S. Constitution It provides that the federal government’s judicial
power is vested in one “Supreme Court.” This court is the U.S. Supreme Court.
administration of the U.S. Supreme Court.
Choice-of-law clause—A contract provision that designates a certain state’s law or
country’s law that will be applied in any dispute concerning nonperformance of the
contract.
CircuitThe geographical area served by each U.S. court of appeals.
page-pf7
Courts and Jurisdiction
15
and other business issues.
Dissenting opinionAn opinion which sets forth the reason why a justice of the Supreme
Court does not agree with a decision.
DistrictThe geographical area served by a U.S. district court.
District of Columbia CircuitThe 12th circuit court, located in Washington DC.
statutes and regulations.
FISA warrantA warrant issued by a FISA Court for the government to conduct
surveillance against persons who are suspected of being threats to national security.
Forum-selection clauseContract provision that designates a certain court to hear any
dispute concerning nonperformance of the contract.
Highest state courtThe highest court in a state court system; it hears appeals from
intermediate appellate state courts and certain trial courts.
In personam jurisdiction (personal jurisdiction)Jurisdiction over the parties to a
lawsuit.
of the lawsuit.
Intermediate appellate court (appellate court or court of appeals)An intermediate court
that hears appeals from trial courts.
International Shoe Company v. State of WashingtonA landmark U.S. Supreme Court
case that established the minimum contacts standard.
specialized or limited nature.
Long-arm statuteA statute that extends a state’s jurisdiction to nonresidents who were
not served a summons within the state.
Majority decisionA decision of the U.S. Supreme Court where a majority of the
justices agree as to the outcome and reasoning used to decide a case.
outcome.
page-pf8
Chapter 2
16
defendant located in another state.
Rule of fourThe votes of four justices are necessary to grant an appeal and schedule an
Service of processA summons is served on the defendant to obtain personal
jurisdiction over him or her.
jurisdiction.
Standing to sueThe plaintiff must have some stake in the outcome of the lawsuit.
State courtsA separate court system that is present in each state, Washington DC and
each territory of the United States. It includes limited-jurisdiction trial courts, general-
jurisdiction trial courts, intermediate appellate courts, and a supreme court.
located in Washington DC.
Tie decisionA Supreme court decision where the number of votes cast by the justices
leads to a tie and the decision of the lower court is affirmed. It occurs when all nine
judges are not present.
Unanimous decisionA Supreme court decision where all the justices voting agree as to
bankruptcy laws.
U.S. Courts of Appeals—The federal court system’s intermediate appellate court.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed ForcesSpecial federal court that exercises
appellate jurisdiction over members of the armed services.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal CircuitA court of appeals located in Washington
International Trade.
U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans ClaimsSpecial federal court that exercises
jurisdiction over decisions of the Department of Veterans Affairs.
U.S. Court of Federal ClaimsSpecial federal court that hears cases brought against the
United States.
tariffs and international trade disputes.
U.S. district courts—The federal court system’s trial courts of general jurisdiction.
Washington DC.
U.S. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court of Review (FISCR)A special federal
a FISA warrant.
U.S. House of Representatives One of the two legislative bodies that make up the
page-pf9
Courts and Jurisdiction
17
national security.
U.S. Tax CourtSpecial federal court that hears cases that involve federal tax laws.
VenueA concept that requires lawsuits to be heard by the court with jurisdiction that is
Writ of certiorari—An official notice that the Supreme Court will review one’s case.

Trusted by Thousands of
Students

Here are what students say about us.

Copyright ©2022 All rights reserved. | CoursePaper is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university.