h) The exceptions merchants gained from parliament included exclusive use of licenses, tariffs, quotas and
other protectionist measures.
i) Even though Smith favored laissez-faire, he also favored the state enforcing competition to help the market
function properly. He feared what today is known as rent-seeking, which occurs when the state rigs the
market in ways that favor or rewards certain (powerful) businesses.
j) For these reasons the state was also visible in that state power was necessary to make the market work
properly in the face of capitalists who would destroy the market.
k) In The Theory of Moral Sentiments, the market must be proactively structured in such a way as to produce
righteous and prudent people. Sounding like Marx, Smith said “the welfare of servants, laborers, and
workmen of different kinds” should be the prime concern of economic policy.
l) Serving one’s own interests in a competitive society means competing to best serve the interests of others,
to behave honestly, and to gain a reputation for fairness.
THE TRANSFORMATION OF LIBERAL IDEAS AND POLICIES
a) Smith’s writings were part of a broader intellectual movement that engendered intense economic and
political change in society. Other writers in this rubric included John Locke and Thomas Jefferson.
b) Liberal political philosophy holds that in order for markets to work, people need to have negative rights
(freedom from state interference and freedom from unlawful imprisonment), along with positive rights
(freedom to do certain basic things such as freedom of speech), and a participatory democratic form of
government to guarantee the positive and negative rights.
c) Economic liberals focus on the domain in which nation–states show their cooperative, peaceful,
constructive natures through harmonious competition.
d) International trade is a positive-sum game that benefits all parties, and not a cutthroat zero-sum competition
as mercantilists assume.
e) Smith condemned tariffs (taxes) and most state restrictions on trade, but did support the mercantilist
Navigation Acts that protected British industries
f) David Ricardo was one of the first economists to explore the scientific principles of free trade, arguing that
using talents and resources appropriately and trading for other goods and services created maximum
economic benefit to the trading parties.
g) These positive-sum payoffs bind states together by common interests in economic intercourse.
h) Economic liberal supporters of globalization argue that strong ties of mutual advantage weaken the need for
national security and war while helping generate a “universal society.”
i) Ricardo vehemently opposed the Corn Laws (see Corn Laws box on p. 33)
Box: Britain’s Corn Laws
a) The Corn Laws were restrictions on food imports enacted by Britain in 1815 to protect the agricultural
interests that then dominated Parliament.
b) Industrial interests and liberals, including Ricardo, opposed the Corn Laws, as they increased production
costs, reduced profit, and limited the amount that other nations imported from Britain.
c) After the Corn Laws were repealed in 1846, industrial production and exports increased, allowing for short-
term expansion of the British economy and building national wealth and power.
JOHN STUART MILL AND THE EVOLUTION OF THE LIBERAL PERSPECTIVE
a) Mill doubted the extent to which the competitive process and economic freedom of capitalism would turn
the pursuit of self-interest into the service of society’s welfare.
b) Selective state intervention in the market, including educating children and assisting the poor, would help
correct the market’s inherent inequalities.
c) As liberalism evolved, laissez-faire was still the guiding principle; however, liberals had to accept some
governmental interference in the market to achieve a number of social objectives.
JOHN MAYNARD KEYNES AND THE GREAT DEPRESSION
a) Keynesianism refers to the ideas and policy recommendations of John Maynard Keynes during the Great
Depression. Like Mill, Keynes believes that there are situations where the state must play a larger but still
limited role in the economy in order act to protect society from the negative effects of infallible markets.