17. Nevil Shute was a British/Australian author and an aeronautical engineer and highly
successful in both careers. He wrote an influential book entitled “No Highway” about a
post-World War II British airliner he called the “Reindeer”4.
The narrator is a hard driving government employed aeronautical engineer, Dr. Scott,
who takes over a laboratory staffed by over-the-hill specialists, most of whom he quickly
retires. But one metallurgist, Mr. Honey, is a quiet and unassuming scientist (but iron
willed). He is working on stress fracture5 of the tail plane of the Reindeer. Mr. Honey
says the tail unit will catastrophically fail in a certain number of flight hours and Dr.
Scott wonders if Mr. Honey is just another over-the-hill specialist. In fact a full scale
experiment of the Reindeer tail section of Mr. Honey’s is already underway to test for
stress fractures. Mr. Honey’s projection for a catastrophic failure is already overdue.
Then a Reindeer crashes killing all on board in remote Canada (while unfortunately
carrying a Soviet ambassador and causing an international incident).
Could Mr. Honey have been right all along? Should Dr. Scott have grounded the
Reindeer when he first heard of Mr. Honey’s theory? Or was his impression of Mr.
Honey as ineffectual correct?
Is there an ethical dilemma here? If Dr. Scott thinks Mr. Honey is wrong why has Mr.
Honey been allowed to waste the government’s money on a large and useless
experiment? On the other hand, if Dr. Scott believes Mr. Honey, why didn’t he ground
the Reindeer immediately?
Use an Engineering Ethics Matrix with these top line choices for Dr. Scott (you can add
more of your own).
4 The world’s first passenger jet was the Comet. (Reindeer and Comet seem to be related by a well-known
Santa poem!) The Comet did suffer from stress fatigue cracking and several aircraft went down with 100%
fatalities by the time the problem was fixed.
5 Take a piece of a tin can and bend it back and fro. It will eventually crack. This is a stress fracture.